President Samia Suluhu Hassan, who is seeking re-election in the October 2025 poll, increasingly resembles her predecessor, John Pombe Magufuli . Before he died in office in 2021 , he banned media, censored journalists, hamstrung the opposition and rigged elections. Hassan is reverting to his tactics to lengthen her advantage in the elections.
Yet, I would go further. Hassan has become, in key ways, more autocratic than Magufuli. She has crossed autocratic thresholds that have not been breached since Tanzania’s transition to multipartyism in 1992 . Most crucially, she has put her chief opponent Tundu Lissu on trial for treason . She has kept another out of the presidential race. Additionally, perhaps her most vocal critic within her own party has been abducted .
Tanzanian opposition leader and former presidential candidate of CHADEMA party, Tundu Lissu, reacts as he arrives at the Kisutu Resident Magistrate's Court in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania June 2, 2025.
Photo credit: Reuters
I have been writing about autocracy in Tanzania and chronicling the struggles of Tanzania’s opposition for over a decade. From this vantage point, I describe what makes this election different.
Many authoritarian regimes today take the form of what political scientists call electoral authoritarianism . It is a mixture of the outward form of multiparty democracy and autocratic practices that tilt the playing field in the incumbent’s favour.
Yet, the steps taken by Hassan’s regime amount to something more draconian than this.
Hassan has broken Tanzania’s political norms, and done so now, it seems, because the international context permits it more than any time in the last 30 years.
The ominous implication of all this is that an era of autocratic rule – which is yet more extreme than any endured in the last 30 years – has arrived.
In one way or another, Tanzania’s regime has been autocratic for decades. The party in power today, Chama cha Mapinduzi , has been in power since independence from Britain in 1961.
Tanzania's then Vice President Samia Hassan Suluhu (L) with the late John Magufuli at State House in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania, in 2019. While Magufuli did not allow pregnant students to return to school, Suluhu's administration breathed life to hopeless teen mothers.
Media were banned, opposition parties were knee-capped, journalists were censored, activists were persecuted, and at large, freedoms were infringed. In the 2020 elections, there appeared to be mass manipulation across Zanzibar and Tanzania for the first time.
In some respects, despite promises of change, Hassan has picked up where Magufuli left off after his death.
In this context, much coverage has understandably drawn analogies from Hassan’s presidency to Magufuli’s. Yet Hassan has been crossing democratic red lines that Magufuli never did, even if he might have wanted to.
The leader of the opposition has been charged with non-bailable offenses, twice.
Freeman Mbowe was charged with terrorism offences and held for 226 days until his release in 2022. His successor, Tundu Lissu , who survived an assassination attempt in 2017, has been detained since 9 April 2025 . He’s now facing trial on charges of treason, a crime punishable by death.
Tanzania’s opposition leader Tundu Lissu before the Kisutu Resident Magistrate’s Court.
Photo credit: The Citizen
Magufuli had these and other opposition leaders arrested a number of times. Yet he did not have them charged with offences of such magnitude. Nor did he have them held for so long.
Hassan has found a way to eliminate her other most significant competitor from the race. Luhaga Mpina was prevented from submitting nomination forms to enter the presidential election as the candidate for Alliance for Change-Wazalendo. This was after a last-minute intervention from the registrar of political parties, who is a presidential appointee.
The consequence is that Hassan is running to be re-elected as the president of Tanzania opposed only by minor candidates.
In case the normal array of media control and military displays of force are not enough to quell the prospect of protest, the regime has shut down the internet early. It has not, as under Magufuli, imposed a post-election blackout . Instead, it has banned social media platforms X, Clubhouse and Telegram, which have been blocked nationwide. Vibrant local social media platform JamiiForums has been taken down.
Meanwhile, the rhythm of state-sponsored violence against opposition activists has been maintained. These include a spate of abductions. On 6 October 2025, ruling party veteran turned Hassan critic Humphrey Polepole was abducted . The police had earlier said he was being investigated for criminal speech.
On the other, opposition leader Lissu has been escorted in and out of court, where, representing himself, he has been declaring his trial a political persecution.
Tanzanian opposition leader and former presidential candidate of CHADEMA party Tundu Lissu gestures to his supporters as he arrives at the Kisutu Resident Magistrate Court in Dar es Salaam, Tanzania May 19, 2025.
In effect, a new era of authoritarianism is crystallising in Tanzania, one in which electoral competition is all but absent at the presidential level. Recent anonymous calls for the military to intervene in Tanzanian politics should be read in this context.
Hassan alone knows her true motives for these changes, but her actions should be read in the international context. Under President Donald Trump’s second term, the US has retreated from global democracy promotion . Heavy cuts in aid budgets have weakened the west’s political might.
In this context, Hassan seems to have explored her room for autocratic manoeuvre, and found international norms giving way before her.
She is not alone in doing so. Today, Turkish opposition leader Ekrem Imamoğlu is in jail awaiting trial on terrorism charges. Mozambican opposition leader Venancio Mondlane is awaiting trial facing terrorism offences.
Amid a world in flux, Hassan, and others, are testing what is left of a liberal world order. So far, they must like what they are finding.
Written by Dan Paget, Assistant Professor at the University of Sussex.
