Sifuna’s options after ODM upheld ouster as secretary-general

As allies push for him to occupy a place on the 2027 presidential ticket and rivals question whether he has the numbers, resources and structures to sustain his momentum, analysts say Mr Sifuna must now decide whether to “fight, flee, negotiate or gamble.”

While the tribunal invalidated ODM's attempt to remove him as secretary-general without granting him a fair hearing, it simultaneously gave the party the green light to proceed with disciplinary proceedings against him.

The verdict handed both sides a partial victory but also exposed the widening gulf between Mr Sifuna and Dr Oburu Oginga-led faction aligned with the party's broad-based cooperation arrangement with President William Ruto's administration.

For the 43-year-old lawyer, the ruling raises a defining question: what next?

Should he remain in ODM and fight for the soul of the party? Should he break away and form his own political vehicle? Could he emerge as a running mate to any of the United Opposition figures - Kalonzo Musyoka or Fred Matiang'i? Should he gamble on a presidential bid powered by youthful support? Or should he take the safer route and defend his Nairobi Senate seat while positioning himself for a bigger role in 2032?

The answers, analysts say, could determine whether Mr Sifuna becomes a major national figure or joins the long list of Kenyan politicians whose momentum evaporated after reaching the peak of public attention.

At the same time, ongoing discussions between Linda Mwananchi leaders and the United Opposition have fueled speculation about a possible Ukombozi-Linda Mwananchi Alliance, with some insiders envisioning a Kalonzo-Sifuna ticket while others are pushing for a Kalonzo-Matiang'i or Matiang'i-Kalonzo combination backed by networks associated with former President Uhuru Kenyatta.

Political analysts say the tribunal ruling may have accelerated decisions Mr Sifuna could previously afford to postpone.

Option One: Stay in ODM and fight from within

Political analyst Mark Bichachi argues that resignation would be politically costly for Mr Sifuna because it would trigger a by-election for the Nairobi Senate seat.

"Sifuna must remain an ODM member until he is ready for an election. Resigning will trigger a by-election. This is a fate no one wants," Mr Bichachi says.

Remaining in ODM, he argues, allows Mr Sifuna to continue enjoying the legitimacy, structures and national network associated with one of Kenya's strongest political parties.

It also buys him time, he says.

Prof Gitile Naituli argues that despite his troubles, Mr Sifuna remains one of Kenya's most recognisable politicians.

"Edwin Sifuna is certainly at an important political crossroads, but crossroads in politics often create opportunities rather than endings," says Prof Naituli, Professor of Management and Leadership, Multimedia University of Kenya.

"He remains one of the country's most visible and articulate politicians and has built a national profile that extends well beyond Nairobi."

There still, however, exists a challenge, say analysts.

ODM's disciplinary machinery is now active. Even if Mr Sifuna survives legal challenges, he risks isolation within party structures.

“The emergence of alternative aspirants for the Nairobi Senate seat, including Lang'ata MP Phelix Odiwuor, suggests ODM may already be preparing for a future beyond him.”

Option Two: Defend Nairobi Senate seat and wait for 2032

Many analysts view this as the safest and perhaps smartest route.

Prof Naituli believes Sifuna's greatest strengths currently lie in legislative leadership and coalition-building rather than presidential politics.

"He could seek re-election as Nairobi Senator, where he retains considerable visibility and political capital," he says.

Political commentator Javas Bigambo shares a similar view.

"Sifuna is harvesting enviable political attention and eyeballs, the thirst of every politician," says Mr Bigambo.

"But his political backbone is not strong enough for a presidential contest just yet."

Mr Bigambo argues that Mr Sifuna should focus on Senate re-election while positioning himself as a major national player for 2032.

Such a strategy would allow him to consolidate support, build grassroots networks and avoid the risk of political overreach.

Option Three: Become Kalonzo Musyoka’s running mate

This option is increasingly gaining attention within opposition circles.

Sources within both Linda Mwananchi and the United Opposition indicate discussions have taken place around a possible Ukombozi-Linda Mwananchi Alliance.

Funyula MP Wilberforce Oundo insists that any coalition arrangement must include Sifuna on the presidential ticket.

"Our very bare minimum is that one of us has to be on the ticket. That person is Sifuna. His face and name must be on the presidential ballot," argues Mr Oundo.

For Mr Musyoka, pairing with Mr Sifuna could inject youthfulness and urban appeal into his campaign, while for Mr Sifuna, it would instantly elevate him from opposition firebrand to potential Deputy President.

The challenge is that Mr Musyoka’s camp is reportedly weighing other options, including a joint ticket with Dr Matiang'i, which many strategists believe could command a stronger financial backing from former President Uhuru Kenyatta, the Jubilee Party leader.

Option Four: Become Fred Matiang'i's running mate

If the opposition settles on Matiang'i as its presidential candidate, some analysts say Mr Sifuna could emerge as a compromise running mate, but caution that this ticket will be more of a Western Kenya affair.

“Dr Matiang’i can best be paired by a running mate from Mt Kenya region,” argues advocate Chris Omore.

He however, contends that Mr Sifuna’s youthful appeal, communication skills and growing support among urban voters could complement any presidential candidate’s image.

The two camps have reportedly held discussions in recent months.

Analysts say that an arrangement with Mr Sifuna as a presidential running mate would allow him to remain relevant nationally without carrying the immense burden of leading a presidential campaign.

They say this option may be more realistic than a direct presidential run.

Option Five: Run for President

Among youthful supporters, this remains the most exciting prospect.

Mr Sifuna's Linda Mwananchi movement has gained traction across the country, particularly among young voters frustrated with traditional political elites.

Saboti MP Caleb Amisi has openly argued that the country needs new faces.

"If Sifuna is not going to be a presidential candidate, the only person I will allow Sifuna to deputise is Maraga (former Chief Justice David Maraga)," Mr Amisi declared, warning that all those politicians who worked under former President Daniel Arap Moi should pave way in 2027.

Political analyst Herman Manyora believes Mr Sifuna is enjoying tremendous momentum.

"Edwin Sifuna is a man on a forward march, propelled by the winds of fortune.  He's therefore unlikely to stop to listen to people who are likely to derail or delay his march,” he argues.

Mr Dismas Mokua however, warns that Mr Sifuna risks being consumed by unrealistic ambitions if he mistakes visibility for political infrastructure.

"While he is enjoying unprecedented national visibility and support, he must translate that visibility into grassroots infrastructure, political capital and financial resources," says Mr Mokua.

The reality, he argues, is that presidential politics requires billions of shillings, nationwide networks and extensive mobilisation structures.

Option Six: Form his own political party

This option has become increasingly plausible as tensions within ODM intensify.

The Linda Mwananchi movement already enjoys growing support and includes influential figures such as Siaya Governor James Orengo, Embakasi East MP Babu Owino and other anti-broad-based government leaders.

Mr Mokua believes a dramatic breakaway could significantly boost Mr Sifuna's stature.

"Sifuna can rock the boat by causing a by-election and running on his party. He will pronounce his political arrival if he wins."

But the risks are enormous.

Without ODM's structures, he says, Mr Sifuna would be forced to build a national party almost from scratch while simultaneously fighting established political giants.

Kakamega Deputy Governor Ayub Savula has warned that Mr Sifuna's popularity may not easily translate into votes outside ODM.

Option Seven: Join President Ruto

Though unlikely, some analysts believe politics should never rule out improbable outcomes.

Mr Bigambo suggests Mr Sifuna could leverage his popularity to negotiate a major national role.

"He could mobilise the younger generation and negotiate with President Ruto for a prime national position," he says. “Left to his own devices, his political backbone is not strong enough for a presidential contest just yet.”

Such a move would, however, carry huge political costs.

Much of Mr Sifuna's current appeal stems from his identity as one of President Ruto's fiercest critics. Crossing over could alienate the very constituency that has elevated him into national prominence.

But beyond popularity and coalition arithmetic, political pundits say, lies a more uncomfortable question: money.

Campaign financing remains one of the biggest considerations facing opposition leaders.

Analysts note that while Mr Sifuna enjoys impressive visibility, a presidential campaign requires extensive resources and organisational capacity.

This reality partly explains why discussions within opposition circles continue to revolve around Mr Musyoka and Dr Matiang'i, both of whom are perceived to possess stronger political networks and fundraising capabilities largely from Mr Kenyatta.

Mr Mokua argues that Mr Sifuna must first convert public goodwill into sustainable political capital.

"While it is clear that Kalonzo Musyoka and Fred Matiang'i are the obvious and viable opposition candidates, Sifuna can position himself and influence the 2027 electoral outcomes to serve his political ambitions."

Also read: Martha Karua: 'I will visit Uganda after Museveni's exit'

Prof Naituli argues that the PPDT ruling has not ended Mr Sifuna's political future. “If anything, it has forced him to confront decisions that will shape the next decade of his career.”

"If he demonstrates strategic patience, maintains his national appeal and positions himself as a principled and effective leader, this period could become a stepping stone rather than a setback," Prof Naituli told Sunday Nation.

For the outspoken Nairobi senator, insiders believe, a direct presidential run remains tempting but risky.

They also argue that forming a new party could redefine him—or destroy him, while joining president Ruto would likely be viewed as political betrayal by many supporters.

Follow our WhatsApp channel for breaking news updates and more stories like this.

[email protected]