Hello

Your subscription is almost coming to an end. Don’t miss out on the great content on Nation.Africa

Ready to continue your informative journey with us?

Hello

Your premium access has ended, but the best of Nation.Africa is still within reach. Renew now to unlock exclusive stories and in-depth features.

Reclaim your full access. Click below to renew.

Man dies in police custody after arrest following domestic brawl

Family in Nakuru seeks answers following kin's death in police custody

On November 15, Mary Nyambura, 43, got into an argument with her boyfriend, Rufus Mutuku, 44, over the destruction of property at her rented house while she was away.

She learnt of the damage on her way home when she met Mutuku, who apologised and said he had destroyed her property, believing she was inside the house.

In an interview, Ms Nyambura said that upon arriving home and assessing the extent of the destruction, she immediately contacted the house agent to report the damage and requested him to visit the following morning to assess the loss and establish how much she would be required to pay.

However, what should have been a discussion about the damaged property quickly turned violent.

Mr Mutuku allegedly kicked Ms Nyambura in the face before strangling her. Their friend attempted to intervene and separate the two, but Mr Mutuku allegedly turned on her as well, assaulting her.

Ms Nyambura said Mr Mutuku then turned on the cooking gas cylinder, leaving it running before closing the door. It took the intervention of two neighbours, who managed to open the door and carry the cylinder outside, to avert what could have escalated into a bigger tragedy.

Fearing for her safety, Ms Nyambura decided to seek police intervention at Kiamaina Police Post.

"I did not know what he would do next, so I rushed to the police post and reported the matter. He heard me saying I was going to the station and followed me, where he surrendered. He came and asked officers which cell he would be placed in and was directed there. He admitted he had wronged me and said he would return in the morning so that we could solve our differences,” she said.

According to Ms Nyambura, at around 9am the following morning, she called the officer handling her case and was instructed to proceed to the station, where she was asked whether she intended to pursue the matter.

She said she explained that she was not interested in having her boyfriend prosecuted but had only sought police intervention to ensure they were separated and that the damage to her property was addressed.

She requested to speak to Mr Mutuku so they could agree on how to resolve the matter, but officers asked her to wait, saying they first wanted to visit her residence to assess the damage.

“We went home and they documented everything before we returned to the station. I spent several hours there while they managed me. Whenever I sought information about Mutuku, they were just taking me in circles. At 1pm, I excused myself because my phone was running low. They told me to return after 30 minutes and not to switch off my phone,” she recalled.

While at home, Ms Nyambura said she received another call from the police, with officers directing her to urgently board a motorcycle and return to the station, where she received devastating news.

She said officers informed her that Mr Mutuku had died by suicide, although they allegedly offered another explanation that he had been assaulted by a mob before being brought to the station.

Ms Nyambura disputed the claims, maintaining that the only injury she had noticed was on his hand, which he had sustained while breaking the window of her house.

"He was okay when he went into the cells. I just wonder how someone can be taken into custody and hours later you are told he is dead. He could not have taken his life because the disagreement between us had not escalated to that level. Then I was not told in the morning; I was informed in the afternoon,” she said.

Ms Nyambura said she and Mutuku had been together for one year and eight months and had never engaged in a physical fight before the incident. She described him as someone who occasionally quarrelled but had never been violent towards her.

"I do not understand why they would allow him into the cells if, as they later claimed, he had been beaten by members of the public. Why was he not taken to hospital first? I want the matter investigated and the truth to be known,” she said.

Police give account of events

Nakuru North Sub-County Police Commander Elisha Obado confirmed the death, saying the incident had been referred to the Independent Policing Oversight Authority (IPOA) for investigation.

He said Ms Nyambura had lodged a complaint at the station at around midnight over malicious damage to property and assault before leaving.

According to Mr Obado, Ms Nyambura returned about an hour later, accompanied by neighbours and members of the public, who brought in a suspect she accused of assaulting her.

The sub-county police commander said Mr Mutuku was booked at the station and placed in custody while appearing drunk. He was alone in the cell.

However, officers discovered his body at about 6am when they went to inspect the cell.

“We lost one person in custody. The matter was taken over by IPOA for further investigation. The lady complained of a misunderstanding between her and the suspect. The officers found the suspect had hanged himself using trousers on the window grills,” he said.

Activist calls for independent probe

Nakuru human rights activist David Kuria has called on IPOA to conduct a fair investigation to establish the circumstances that led to Mr Mutuku's death while in police custody.

“The circumstances leading to the man's death, including whether he sustained injuries before or during his detention, remain subject to investigation. IPOA is expected to help establish what happened while the man was in custody and whether proper procedures were followed,” he said.

Follow our WhatsApp channel for breaking news updates and more stories like this.