Despite so many cases coming out publicly of artistes fighting to come out of bad deals with labels or talent management companies, we still see more artistes revealing they signed contracts that they later regret.
Lifestyle reporter Sinda Matiko talks to IP lawyers on what may lead one to make the decision that they claim is unfair down the line.
When the fallout between Tanzania's Wasafi Classic Baby (WCB) Records, owned by superstar Diamond Platnumz, and its first signed artiste, Harmonize, erupted in 2019, it quickly became one of the biggest talking points in East Africa's music industry.
Diamond Platnumz and Harmonize.
Photo credit: File | Nation Media Group
The dispute, sparked by Harmonize's attempts to force his way out of what he described as an exploitative contract, drew attention beyond Tanzania, with even players in Kenya's music industry weighing in.
Harmonize's journey to stardom began with Diamond, who discovered him in 2016, when he was still an unknown artiste struggling to find his footing in the competitive Bongo music industry.
Before Diamond took him under his wing, Harmonize had struggled to make ends meet. His fortunes had been so bleak that he had even been eliminated from the music talent competition Bongo Star Search after failing to convince the judges of his musical abilities.
Diamond, however, saw potential. He signed Harmonize as the first artiste under his then newly-established WCB Records, investing his money, industry connections and influence in developing his musical career.
Under the label, Harmonize received the production, marketing and promotional machinery that would eventually transform him from an obscure aspiring musician into one of Tanzania's most recognisable music stars.
But four years into the relationship, the now-established artiste began questioning the price of that transformation. Harmonize took issue with his contract that entitled WCB to 60 percent of his music-related earnings, ranging from performance fees and streaming royalties to brand endorsement deals.
He considered the arrangement exploitative and sought to terminate the relationship, arguing that the label's share of his earnings was not justifiable.
Walking away, however, proved considerably more expensive than he had anticipated.
Even the intervention of Tanzania's arts regulatory body, the National Arts Council (BASATA), to mediate the acrimonious separation did not offer an easy way out.
The council established that Harmonize had signed a binding 10-year agreement with WCB, meaning he could not simply terminate the relationship and walk away with his music.
To secure his freedom, he had to buy out the remainder of his contract, paying the label Sh25 million.
Raising the money required him to take out loans and sell some of his assets, including a house and a piece of land. The separation was eventually concluded after the payment, with WCB handing over control of his music catalogue to him.
Diamond, for his part, was unapologetic about the label's position. He argued that he had invested millions of shillings in building Harmonize's career and was entitled to recover that investment, together with a profit, under the terms of their agreement.
“Music is business, and as such there are contractual obligations between parties agreed to. Those complaining seem to forget that we took these artistes, moulded them to a point where they were now marketable and able to generate good money, unlike before. I did this by investing millions of shillings of my own money into them, but when an artiste is now established, he wants to run away with the whole business. I can't allow that,” Diamond said in an interview.
At the time, the dispute offered a glimpse into the often-uncomfortable economics of the relationship between record labels and the artistes whose careers they finance and build. Yet, despite the publicity surrounding the Harmonize saga, the lessons appear not to have travelled far enough.
Today, Kenyan Gengetone artiste Fathermoh finds himself embroiled in a strikingly similar dispute with Black Market Records, a US-based record label that took him in, provided financial support for his rent and upkeep, and invested in his music career.
Musician Moses Otieno, popularly known as Fathermoh addressing participants during BoomFest Music Festival announcement launch by Boomplay at Nairobi Street Kitchen on March 14, 2024.
Photo credit: Bonface Bogita | Nation
Although the precise contractual terms governing their relationship remain to be established, the label's involvement in his career has left it with control over a significant portion of the proceeds from his music catalogue during the period he was signed to it.
In May, Fathermoh sued the label, seeking Sh87 million in alleged unpaid royalties.
He accused Black Market Records of unlawfully monetising his music, infringing his copyright and denying him control over his catalogue following their fallout and his departure from the label.
The dispute, which has now been cleared to be heard by the Copyright Tribunal after the High Court determined it had jurisdiction on November 12, has since sparked debate over who should ultimately own and control the commercial value of music created by artistes whose careers are financed by record labels.
What we know of Fathermoh-Black Markets Record Contract
Fathermoh entered into an exclusive recording agreement with BMR in 2021, according to his court filings.
Under the agreement, the label was to produce, distribute, and market his music in exchange for a 20 percent share of royalties and 50 percent publishing rights. Between then and 2024, he says he released 63 songs, both as a solo artiste and a member of the Mbuzi Gang group also signed under the label.
He claims he invested his own money in recording, music production and collaborations with the expectations he would recoup his money through publishing and streaming revenue.
Musical artist Fathermoh performs during the unveiling of Chrome’s bold new pack design under the Street Filosofia campaign at KICC in Nairobi on March 30, 2025.
Photo credit: Bonface Bogita | Nation
However, he alleged his former label took control of his music catalogue, monetised his music across digital streaming platforms such as YouTube, Spotify, and Boomplay, but failed to remit his royalties.
Fathermoh also claims the label issued several copyright strikes and takedown notices whenever he attempted to release new music or reuse his own content since leaving the label, thus disrupting his efforts to operate as an independent artiste.
He also accuses BMR of falsely claiming ownership of his songs, registering them under different names and withholding access to his catalogue, effectively locking him out of his own work.
He argues the effect of that has seen his streams significantly drop with his Spotify monthly listeners dropping from 80,000 to 46,000 along a sharp decline of his subscribers on YouTube and advertising revenue. On that basis, he argues his contract with BMR is null and void and wants the courts to squash it as he seeks Sh87.6 million in alleged unpaid royalties and publishing revenue, in addition to special damages and reimbursement of production costs incurred on several music projects.
What music executives are saying
According to Angela Ndambuki, an Intellectual Property expert and chairperson of the Kenya Association of Music Producers and former musician, many artistes enter into 360-degree contractual deals that give labels significant control of their music.
“Under a 360-degree deal, the label has access to an artiste's image rights, copyright, performance fees, syndication fees, royalties, publishing rights and virtually every other stream of income the artiste earns,” she noted.
For Record labels, 360 agreements are always the catch.
"What many do not know is that all these other perks are considered loans from the record label, an investment the label makes in an artiste. And like any other investment, a healthy return is expected."
From where David Katee, an IP expert and High Court Advocate, sits, the appeal of such arrangements for many artistes lies in the promise of financial backing, marketing, distribution and professional career management. But the trade-off can be costly.
“A 360 deal is always a multi-rights agreement that allows record labels to claim a substantial share of the revenue generated from music sales, publishing, touring, performances and virtually every other commercial activity linked to an artiste. That scenario leaves artistes with pretty much little control over their musical works. Artistes should be vigilant about what they sign and, even better, they need to engage IP lawyers to understand and interpret these contracts before they sign,” says Mr Katee.
He says that instead of taking time to read between the lines or engaging IP lawyers, many artistes rush into signing contracts once a mouth-watering offer is put on the table.
“I recall cautioning a Kenyan big star from signing an album recording deal with an affiliate of one of the world's biggest recording labels, but I was ignored. I had gone through the contract, and I pointed out a number of red flags. But I guess the Sh6 million the contract offered was so tempting, and so the artiste chose to ignore my advice and sign it. Long story short, the artist only received a fraction of the money promised, and the album didn't do well. The artiste later came out publicly to air frustration and regrets.”