Hello

Your subscription is almost coming to an end. Don’t miss out on the great content on Nation.Africa

Ready to continue your informative journey with us?

Hello

Your premium access has ended, but the best of Nation.Africa is still within reach. Renew now to unlock exclusive stories and in-depth features.

Reclaim your full access. Click below to renew.

Lawyers want MPs ordered to testify in Saitoti death probe

What you need to know:

  • On June 28, the MPs claimed Prof Saitoti and his deputy Mr Ojodeh were assassinated by drug barons.
  • Lawyer Evans Monari is demanding MPs Gideon Konchellah, Martha Karua, William Kabogo, Jakoyo Midiwo, Kiema Kilonzo, Isaac Ruto and Rachel Shebesh be summoned.
  • Judge Kalpana Rawal said the commission had already written to three MPs the team thought had credible information to come forth as witnesses, but were yet to get their response.

The commission of inquiry into the helicopter crash that killed Internal Security Minister George Saitoti has been asked to compel the MPs who claimed drug barons were behind the accident to testify before it winds up the hearings.

The June 10 crash also claimed the lives of Prof Saitoti’s deputy Orwa Ojodeh, their bodyguards Sergeant Thomas Murimi, Joshua Tonkei and pilots Luke Oyugi and Nancy Gituanja.

Lawyer Evans Monari, appearing for the police and Ms Lucy Kambuni, the commission’s assisting counsel, said parliamentary immunity notwithstanding, summons be issued on the MPs to appear and give their evidence “as they had alluded to know the facts behind the helicopter crash.” (READ: Drug lords killed Saitoti, claim MPs)

Mr Monari, who stood to make his point before the start of Wednesday’s hearings and was requested by the commission’s chairperson Lady Justice Kalpana Rawal to sit and speak into the microphone to enhance a Hansard recording, said the MPs’ sentiments bordered on possible assassination.

“These were not pedestrian comments and they can neither be dismissed nor ignored if the commission is to get to the bottom of the matter,” Mr Monari charged.

“I have collected newspaper cuttings dated June 29 and obtained Hansard recordings of June 28 where nine MPs alleged to know what caused the accident.

"Their comments were made at a time when the country was in a state of transition... let the people who made these comments be compelled to appear before this commission and repeat the sentiments they had in Parliament,” he said.

Judge Kalpana Rawal said the commission had already written to three MPs the team thought had credible information to come forth as witnesses, but were yet to get their response.

“These sentiments may have far-reaching implications and I want us to tread carefully, I am aware they have parliamentary privileges, which may not supersede the Constitution of Kenya, which also set up this commission,” the judge said.

“I would like to get to know the legal perimeters here,” she added, saying the lawyers’ concerns be stood over till Friday for judicial consultations to ascertain the legal implications before a final ruling is made. “We need to respond substantively,” she said.

Mr Monari said that when an MP like Aggrey Orengo (Ugenya) likened the Saitoti incident to the late former Foreign Affairs Minister Robert Ouko’s case, he was alluding to an assassination and questioned why the MPs were reluctant to testify. “Are they hiding something?” the lawyer posed.

Ms Kambuni said the public was entitled to know what caused the crash and that the “public’s interest reigned supreme”.

This commission has a jurisdiction to deal with this issue, she said, adding that the team was in its final round of sittings and if the MPs were still willing to record their statements, the doors were wide open.

I want us to tread carefully

The judge said the MPs had a public duty to fulfil and “I still encourage them to come, if they have real information.” She concurred that the issue raised by the lawyers was “serious” and could not be taken lightly.

“But again I want us to tread carefully on this one so that we may gain, rather than lose out in the process.”

The commission agreed to make a ruling in public, but warned that should any sensitive matter arise, then it would be dealt with in closed-door session on Friday.

On June 28, the MPs claimed Prof Saitoti and his deputy Mr Ojodeh were assassinated by drug barons. The MPs had accused the Government of a cover up, saying, foreign investigators were frustrated by the Transport ministry, which hampered their inquiries.

The assassination claim arose in Parliament when Defence Minister Yusuf Haji was responding to a question by Kilome MP Harun Mwau over an allegation by former US ambassador Michael Ranneberger that Eastleigh Moi Air Force base was being used as a narcotic drugs trafficking conduit.

Nominated MP Rachel Shebesh said she had a damning dossier linking drug traffickers in government to the death of Prof Saitoti “... what we have can shut down this government” she was quoted saying.

On Wednesday, Mr Monari demanded MPs Gideon Konchellah, Martha Karua, William Kabogo, Jakoyo Midiwo, Kiema Kilonzo, Isaac Ruto and Rachel Shebesh be summoned.

An air traffic controller who testified before the commission on Wednesday said the pilots flying the ill-fated copter left safely from Wilson Airport, Nairobi, and did not radio back any distress signal that they had encountered adverse weather.

Mr John Minjo said he was in communication with pilot Luke Oyugi and wished each other “a good day”, shortly before he was told the helicopter had crashed at Kibiku in Ngong.

But in cross examination, Mr Monari put it to the witness that he may squarely have to shoulder the blame for having released the chopper to fly should the commission find that the accident was caused by adverse weather.