The International Criminal Court (ICC) Prosecutor Fatou Bensouda has disclosed the identity of three witnesses to Deputy Prime Minister Uhuru Kenyatta.
The prosecutor says that security issues that surrounded the witnesses have been resolved and their identities were disclosed to Mr Kenyatta last week.
“While the Pre‐Trial Chamber authorised the Prosecution to withhold the identities of these witnesses at the confirmation stage due to security concerns, their security situation has changed in the last weeks such that it permits the disclosure of their identities,” Ms Bensouda told the judges.
She added that the prosecution has decided to waive delay in disclosure of the witnesses which has been set for 60 days before April 11, 2013. She also said that her office has informed Mr Kenyatta that it would disclose unredacted or lesser redacted versions of the records of the witnesses’ interviews.
Ms Bensouda has, however, asked the judges to dismiss Mr Kenyatta’s request that she reveals whether she will be relying on the testimonies of these witnesses at trial. She said that the DPM fails to justify this request as the judges have already asked her to provide her list of witnesses by January 9, 2013.
“In terms of trial preparation, the Prosecution has disclosed the identities of the three witnesses, enabling the Defence to “institute immediately thorough investigations” with respect to their evidence.
In terms of efficiency, the Defence cannot reasonably argue that it is unduly burdened by the prospect that one or more of the Prosecution’s pre‐trial witnesses may not testify at trial,” Ms Bensouda said.
The issue of witnesses has been the centre of arguments especially between the prosecutor and Mr Kenyatta, who has more than twice challenged the credibility of the prosecution witnesses.
Mr Kenyatta had written to the court to order the prosecution to disclose the identity of two witnesses and indicate whether it will rely on their evidence.
Mr Kenyatta is seeking the identities of witnesses 11 and 12 and wants to know if the prosecution will rely on their evidence and that of witness 4. The prosecution had been arguing that it cannot reveal the identities of the said witnesses for security reasons.
He wants the Trial Chamber to order the prosecution to disclose the evidence arising from all investigations and all other material including direct or indirect communications to date in respect to the three.
“The defence for Kenyatta seeks specific relief in respect of prosecution Witnesses 4, 11 and 12 at this stage in the proceedings. In particular, the defence requests the following: Confirmation from the prosecution that it intends to rely upon OTP-4, OTP-11 and OTP-12 at trial, and confirmation of the identities of OTP-11 and OTP-12,” the DPM said.
Mr Kenyatta says that April 1, 2011, Witness 11 told a member of his defence support team that there had been “an attempt by ODM to induce the two witnesses to cross-over and testify” for the prosecution. He adds that prior to March 12, 2011, Witnesses 11 and 12 had provided exculpatory evidence to the Defence.
The DPM adds that the prosecution should, in the disclosure, include evidence which tends to show his innocence, or which may affect the credibility of these prosecution witnesses. He argues that witness 4’s statement to the prosecution contradicts that of Witness 11 in relation to the allegations that Mungiki met at State House on November 27, 2007.
“OTP-12 is led by the interviewer to conclude that a number of Mungiki members went to Nairobi State House on 27 November 2007. This allegation contradicts the Prosecution’s own case on the basis of the evidence of OTP-4 who claimed that such a meeting took place on 26 November 2007,” Mr Kenyatta argues.
Mr Kenyatta says that this allegation by the prosecution witness is contradicted by 11 of his witnesses who attended a meeting at State House on November 26, 2007.
He also argues that Witness 12 is led by the investigator to conclude that the DPM and other politicians attended a meeting on December30, 2007, the purpose of which was to mobilise people on the ground. He says that this allegation is contradicted by “significant and credible defence evidence” available to the Trial Chamber, including the evidence of five of his witnesses.
Mr Kenyatta argues that it will be only fair if the defence has that information during the trials which are scheduled to kick off on April 11, next year.
His lawyers are also seeking the court’s permission to use “confidential identifying information, visual and/or non-textual documents for the sole purpose of defence investigations in respect of OTP-4, OTP-11 and OTP-12.”