In Kenya, getting your first job requires three years of experience, a clean suit bought on Fuliza, and the patience to refresh an empty inbox until your bundles run out. If you are lucky, an employer offers an unpaid internship and calls it mentorship.
If, however, you are Francis Atwoli, jobs find you. On October 23, Labour CS Alfred Mutua appointed the Central Organisation of Trade Unions (Cotu) Secretary-General to the National Board for Social Protection for a three-year term. That came barely weeks after Atwoli’s reappointment to the National Labour Board. Two state appointments in under two months for a man who has led Cotu since 2001.
One would think Kenya has run out of professionals to sit on public boards, or that the Ministry of Labour has mistaken state appointments for a retirement scheme for familiar faces. Atwoli meets the statutory requirements to serve under the Social Protection Act, 2025. Still, how these appointments are handed out – and what they mean for the independence of organised labour – deserves scrutiny. Cotu exists to defend workers and push back against policies that hurt them. When its chief is collecting board seats from the very ministry he is meant to hold to account, the public has a right to ask whose interests come first.
Meanwhile, Mutua pitches himself as the man who will solve Kenya’s youth unemployment crisis – not at home, but in the Middle East. On November 13, following talks in Riyadh, he announced that Saudi hiring agencies had committed 293,600 job opportunities for Kenyans.
It is a headline-grabbing number, complete with celebratory photos and staged handshakes. Yet it requires a basic distinction that official press releases gloss over: a commitment by recruitment agencies is not a signed employment contract. In a country where desperation for overseas work is exploited by brokers, promises on paper mean little until workers board planes with verifiable contracts.
That scepticism is warranted, given Mutua’s history. During his August 2024 Cabinet vetting, MPs questioned him over his association with Judy Jepchirchir, director of First Choice Recruitment Agency – a firm accused by hundreds of youths of collecting millions of shillings for overseas jobs and study placements that never materialised. Mutua said he had merely met her at a KICC event and introduced her to President William Ruto.
A Senate inquiry documented families that sold land, took loans and drained their life savings to pay the agency, ultimately recommending refunds. The Ethics and Anti-Corruption Commission (EACC) briefed the Senate on its investigations into the saga. While Mutua was never found guilty of defrauding the applicants, his proximity to a figure at the centre of one of Kenya’s worst recruitment scandals raises questions about oversight now that he runs the Labour docket.
His record as Machakos governor carries baggage. The EACC investigated an allegedly irregular Sh89 million contract for desilting Maruba dam alongside queries over Sh50 million in donor funds. Mutua maintained that the dam work was done and said the donor funds issue had been resolved. No court has convicted him, yet those unresolved audit trails sit uneasily beside his mandate to protect workers from exploitation.
The risks facing Kenyans in the Gulf are well documented. Migrants in Saudi Arabia and neighbouring states have reported seized passports, unpaid wages, abuse and breach of contract. Negotiating headline quotas in Riyadh is the easy part. The real work is vetting the agencies, enforcing standard contracts, tracking every worker and rescuing them from abuse.
There is something bleak about a government that shows more urgency in exporting its labour force than fixing the economy. Kenya is not short of nurses, teachers, engineers, technicians, and graduates. They are willing to work locally, yet they remain locked out of an economy where connections outweigh competence.
Working abroad should be a choice, not an exile forced on young people because their country cannot absorb them.
If Mutua wants Kenyans to take the 293,600 figure seriously, he should publish the names of the Saudi agencies involved, recruitment timelines, vetting criteria and legal safeguards protecting the workers. He should explain what his ministry is doing to ensure families burned by rogue local agencies get their money back.
For now, the Ministry of Labour seems focused on finding exits for young Kenyans and extra titles for entrenched insiders – leaving millions of graduates where they started, refreshing their inboxes.