Government backs new body to investigate suspicious deaths
A cordoned-off crime scene. The ODPP says handling evidence in good faith should not be treated as interference.
What you need to know:
- State agencies have backed a proposed law to establish an independent National Coroners Service to investigate sudden, violent and suspicious deaths.
- However, they want changes to investigation deadlines, post-mortem reporting and penalties for handling evidence at death scenes.
The Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (ODPP), the State Departments for Justice and Interior, and the Chief Government Pathologist have backed the National Coroners Service Bill, 2026. However, several of them want changes to report deadlines, to who signs post-mortem reports, and to penalties that could catch members of the public who handle evidence at death scenes.
They made their submissions to the National Assembly's Departmental Committee on Health, chaired by Seme MP Dr James Nyikal.
The Bill, sponsored by Majority Leader Kimani Ichung'wah, was published on September 4. It would create a statutory National Coroners Service to investigate violent, sudden and suspicious deaths, regulate post-mortems, and approve the transfer of bodies into and out of Kenya. It repeals the existing National Coroners Service Act.
Final report
In a submission signed by DPP Renson Ingonga, the ODPP said it supports an independent and adequately resourced service, but wants revisions. Its main objection is the three-month limit for concluding an investigation and delivering a final report.
"Routine three-month delays would impair charging decisions, custody applications and advance disclosure. A reporting ceiling must not become a permission to withhold available findings," the office said.
The Bill already requires an interim report to police and the ODPP within 24 hours of a post-mortem. The ODPP wants that report signed and actually sent, followed by a signed substantive report within 48 hours where the cause of death is apparent and no major specialist results are pending.
Longer periods should be allowed only with reasons, such as awaiting Government Chemist analysis. The laboratory and expected date should then be named, with updates at least every 14 days.
On clause 40(6), which requires the Coroner-General to sign every report, the ODPP wants the actual examiner or analyst to sign and be available to testify in court.
It also warned about clause 34, which makes it an offence to interfere with or tamper with evidence or a scene where a reportable death occurred. The penalty is a fine of up to Sh500,000, up to two years in prison, or both. A company faces a fine of up to Sh2 million.
"Members of the public often arrive before investigators. They may rush someone who is believed to be alive to hospital, move a person from danger, or pick up an item such as a bullet or cartridge case and hand it to police. These actions can affect evidence, but movement or handling alone should not establish criminal interference," the office said.
It asked that the law distinguish deliberate concealment, destruction or fabrication from reasonable good-faith assistance, rather than leaving the distinction to prosecutorial discretion.
The ODPP flagged further drafting problems. Failure to notify a reportable death carries up to six months in prison. The false statements offence applies where a person knew or ought to have known a statement was false, and the ODPP wants it tied to knowing or reckless falsity.
The Bill also lets the Coroner's Service discontinue an investigation, including where it finds a natural cause or for public health reasons. The ODPP said a coronial closure must not end a criminal investigation or prosecution. It asked for safeguards in violent and custody deaths.
The State Department for Justice, in a memorandum signed by Deputy Solicitor General Lawrence Muiruri Ngugi, said a multi-agency committee set up in 2020 has coordinated the groundwork. It added that the Public Service Commission has approved an organisational structure, career progression guidelines and a human resource manual.
"The State Department therefore supports the enactment of the National Coroners Service Bill, 2026 as a critical legislative measure for the operationalisation of the National Coroners Service. The bill addresses identified gaps in the existing framework by providing greater clarity in governance structures, institutional responsibilities, investigative processes and accountability mechanisms," it said.
Justice PS Judith Pareno, according to a parliamentary press statement on the hearing, told the committee that the Chief Government Pathologist currently performs many of the functions of a public coroner despite limited support.
"One man cannot run around without a structure. The chief government pathologist needs support. We need officers and offices across the country. We must create a well-structured institution that will serve the purpose for which it is intended," she said.
Dr Johansen Oduor, Chief Government Pathologist, mainly recommended that coronial investigations be kept separate from police investigations, prosecutions and judicial determinations. He also asked that reportable deaths be defined by clear and proportionate criteria, and that families get enforceable rights and a national implementation plan with costings.
Forensic evidence
"The Bill provides a sound foundation for a national service. It defines reportable deaths, safeguards forensic evidence, ensures scrutiny of deaths in custody and makes statutory examinations a public responsibility," he said.
Like the ODPP, he opposed a fixed three-month limit for all cases, saying it could either rush complex work or be missed without explanation. He proposed milestones for the initial examination and interim report, extensions for toxicology, DNA and histology tests, periodic family updates and independent monitoring of delays.
On signing, he said the Coroner-General may be unable to sign every report, given administrative duties and the volume of autopsies nationwide. The examining expert, he said, should sign the medical opinion.
He asked that the Kenya Association of Clinical Pathologists be added to the Council. He also asked that the Bill's reference to a representative of Muslims among interested persons be replaced with a religious or cultural adviser nominated by the family, available to families of any faith.
He objected to the Bill's immunity and absolute privilege for people who submit information to the Service, saying they could protect knowingly false submissions. He also cautioned that donations to the Service could create a perception of influence, and asked that fees for core statutory investigations be prohibited.
On funding, he said the system depends on decisions by others and lacks money.
"This and the fragmented nature of the current system hampers service delivery and lacks monitoring and evaluation to guide improvement. Death investigation services also lack funding: with health services devolved, most pathologists and medical officers undertake this work without funding for the associated activities and costs involved," said Dr Oduor.
The Interior Ministry, in a submission signed by Principal Secretary Raymond Omollo, supported the Bill and traced the history of death investigation. Omollo said suspicious deaths before independence were handled through public inquests under the Criminal Procedure Code, with police investigating.
"After independence, this system subsisted until it was felt that investigative agencies needed more independence and accountability in their work. This led to the enactment of the National Coroners Service Act, 2017. This Act was never operationalised. It was felt that it needed critical amendments to ensure that it serves its purpose," he said.
The PS proposed that he sit on the Council because forensic pathologists fall under his State Department. He also asked that the Council recruit the Coroner-General, coroners and staff, and supervise the Service's operations.
The ministry also wants Coroner-General qualifications widened to persons who have studied medicine or law.
"Functions of a coroner-general are not limited to medical matters. They also involve dealing with legal matters. The coroner-general may in some cases receive and analyse evidence and make legal findings on the cause of death," said Omollo.
The ministry also asked that deaths in religious institutions be added to the list of reportable deaths, citing the Shakahola deaths. It further asked that the Bill's objects clause be expanded and that its scope cover the identification, storage and transportation of bodies.
The Kenya Medical Association, represented by consultant pathologist Dr Cynthia Chemonges, backed an independent Service. It said linking forensic pathology with public health surveillance would help address maternal deaths, road traffic fatalities, occupational hazards and deaths in institutional care.
"A well-functioning National Coroners Service should not only establish why people die but must also generate actionable evidence that helps Kenya prevent avoidable deaths. Through this approach, the service becomes a proactive safeguard for the living, rather than a reactive investigator of the dead," she said.
Mortuary technicians and technologists also supported the Bill but asked for legal protection, representation and occupational biosafety guarantees.