The High Court has rejected an attempt by the owners of a cargo ship, Dolphin Star, to overturn an agreement that allowed a company to acquire the vessel and its cargo of timber, ending a fresh attempt to have the ship sold through competitive bidding.
Justice Jairus Ngaah on November 20 dismissed an application by the owners of the vessel seeking to reverse orders made in April 2025, which allowed ET Timbers Pte Limited to acquire the ship for $2.1 million (about Sh271 million) and its cargo of round logs for $135,000 (about Sh17 million).
The owners had argued that ET Timbers failed to pay Kenya Ports Authority (KPA) charges and the expenses of the Admiralty Marshal within 21 days, as required under the agreement reached in court.
They wanted the court to declare the transfer invalid and order a fresh sale through open tender, arguing that the company had failed to meet the agreed payment deadline.
However, Justice Ngaah ruled that the delay in settling the charges did not automatically cancel the agreement or invalidate the subsequent transfer of the vessel.
The judge said the parties had voluntarily agreed to the arrangement, which was recorded in court in the presence of their lawyers, and could not later be reversed simply because one party complained that another had delayed fulfilling an obligation.
"The Defendant’s complaint is not that the bargain was bad at its inception but that the Claimant did not perform one of its terms on time. That is a complaint about performance, not about the validity of the consent," Justice Ngaah ruled.
The dispute arose from a claim filed by ET Timbers against the owners of Dolphin Star, with KPA listed as an interested party.
On May 24, 2024, the High Court entered judgment in favour of ET Timbers and ordered the valuation and sale of the vessel together with the timber cargo it was carrying.
The ruling followed an unsuccessful legal battle by the ship owners, whose appeals against an earlier decision on the court's authority to hear the dispute and the judgment itself were dismissed by the Court of Appeal in April 2025.
Efforts to sell the vessel and its cargo through public tender had also failed twice. The first advertisement, published on September 5, 2024, attracted no bids.
A second attempt was made on March 13, 2025, attracting two bids. However, when the bids were opened on April 11, 2025, neither met the requirements because the bidders had failed to provide the mandatory deposit amounting to 25 per cent of their offers. The auction was consequently declared unsuccessful.
With the two attempts having failed, ET Timbers approached the court on April 14, 2025, offering to take the vessel for $2.1 million and the timber cargo for $135,000 as part of the settlement of the amount owed to it.
The company also undertook to settle KPA's claim against the vessel and meet the Admiralty Marshal's expenses before taking possession.
On April 28, 2025, lawyers representing the three parties agreed to the proposed arrangement, which was formally issued by the Admiralty Marshal on May 21, 2025.
Under the agreement, ET Timbers was not required to make a separate payment for the ship and timber because the amount owed to it, including interest, was higher than the agreed purchase price.
Instead, the company would acquire the vessel and cargo in satisfaction of its claim, while settling the port charges and other expenses.
However, the ship owners later complained that the company had failed to meet the 21-day deadline, which expired on May 19, 2025.
They further claimed that the vessel had remained anchored for too long and was at risk of sinking with its cargo, potentially causing damage to the marine environment. But the judge said these claims had not been supported by reliable evidence.
He questioned why the owners had not presented an officer, representative or other person with direct knowledge of the vessel's condition to support the allegations. The only affidavit supporting the application had been sworn by Patrick Njuguna, an advocate representing the ship owners.
Justice Ngaah said the lawyer could properly testify on matters appearing in court records but could not make unsupported claims about the financial capacity of ET Timbers or the physical condition of the vessel.
"No survey report, no communication from the Admiralty Marshal or the port authority and no statement from the vessel’s owners, master or crew has been exhibited," the judge observed.
He added that he attached no evidential weight to the claims that the purchaser lacked the financial ability to acquire the vessel or that the ship faced an imminent danger of sinking.
The judge also noted that KPA, which was entitled to receive the outstanding charges, had neither supported the application nor complained about delayed payment.
Justice Ngaah said the agreement did not state that failure to settle the charges within 21 days would automatically cancel the sale or force the parties to restart the tendering process.
The judge further observed that the company had since settled the required charges and expenses, and the vessel had been transferred to a new owner and renamed.
He said overturning the completed sale would also affect rights that had already passed to the new owner, who was not a party to the application.
"The court will be slow to undo a completed judicial sale, and slower still at the instance of the judgment debtor whose property was sold, on no better ground than that a payment due to third parties was made late," he ruled.
The judge also questioned the logic of the owners' proposal to advertise the vessel again, given that two previous attempts had failed and they were simultaneously claiming that the ship had deteriorated and was at risk of sinking. He said there was no evidence that a third tender, more than a year later, would attract better offers.
The ruling also addressed an email dated May 29, 2025, in which Defang Shipping Company Limited, described as the vessel's owners, accused the process of being influenced by improper and corrupt practices and demanded an investigation.
The judge said the allegations were not part of the application before him and had not been supported by sworn evidence. He clarified that the April 2025 agreement was not a fresh judgment on the original dispute but an arrangement negotiated by the parties themselves to settle the decree.
"The order of 28 April 2025... decided nothing as between the parties; it recorded the terms upon which the parties, the Defendant included, had themselves agreed that the decree would be satisfied," he said.
Justice Ngaah dismissed the application dated July 1, 2025, and ordered the ship owners to pay the costs of the case.