Kenya’s coach Benni McCarthy has defended his decision to delay substitutions in his team’s 2-1 defeat to South Africa, insisting that his side had momentum and looked the more likely to score.
The return leg of the 2027 Africa Cup of Nations Group ‘D’ qualifier match was played at Nyayo National Stadium in Nairobi on Tuesday.
“Just because the team gives two, three, four misplaced passes and then you want to change and you think it is enough to change the team? I think we had unbelievable momentum, so when things are going your way why would you want to change it?” McCarthy quipped at the post-match press conference.
“At that moment, we looked like we were going to score and Erick Ouma was free on the left every single time and every time we got the ball to him, he whipped in dangerous balls,” McCarthy said when asked whether he felt that Ouma, popularly known as ‘Marcelo’, should have been withdrawn earlier after appearing to fade.
The left-back has only recently returned from a long-term injury, and McCarthy said the criticism around his handling of the player has been contradictory.
“People must not forget he has had a long-term injury, he has had six, seven games under his belt. When he was a substitute in the first game, people were asking why I did not start him. Today he starts, and people are saying ‘why I did not change him’? Honestly, I don’t know what goes on in the football brain because people contradict themselves,” he said.
Despite the growing noise around his tenure, including reports in South Africa labelling him a traitor for collecting a point against his home country, McCarthy insists he is unfazed.
“People will talk. That is football. If we had lost to a small team then I would say okay, you have got every reason to call for me. But South Africa? You need to respect what they are,” he said.
“When you know you have given everything in that short period we have together, when you know the team fights, plays with heart and never says die, I sleep like a baby. I know we are on the right track,” he added.
Kenya’s Michael Olunga (centre) and Erick Ouma vie for a set-piece ball against South Africa’s Olwethu Makhanya on Tuesday during their Group ‘D’ match of 2027 Africa Cup of Nations qualifiers on Tuesday at Nyayo National Stadium in Nairobi. South Africa won 2-1.
Photo credit: Chris Omollo | Nation
Harambee Stars, who have already qualified for the tournament as co-hosts alongside Tanzania and Uganda, were looking to make a statement after a 2-2 draw in the first leg in Johannesburg on Friday, but South Africa showed their experience to move top of Group ‘D’ on 10 points from four matches. Guinea are second with nine points, while Kenya remain third with two points and Eritrea bottom with one.
Before kick-off, captain Michael Olunga was honoured for being Kenya’s all-time top scorer with 35 goals in all competitions. He was awarded a plaque by Sports Cabinet Secretary Salim Mvurya, Principal Secretary Elijah Mwangi and FKF President Hussein Mohammed. McCarthy made four changes to the side that drew in Johannesburg, bringing in England-based Zachary Vyner and Ouma for Abud Omar and Vincent Harper in defence, and handing Alpha Onyango a start in midfield.
Kenya started brightly. In the third minute, a foul on Frank Onyango presented a free-kick that found Olunga, but the Harambee Stars captain headed wide. A minute later, Ouma almost gifted Bafana the opener with a miscalculated back pass, but the visitors lacked composure. In the ninth minute, Marcelo delivered a teasing cross that forced a save from Ronwen Williams.
South Africa have qualified for the tournament 12 times and won it in 1996. On Tuesday, Bafana Bafana fielded team that reached the second round of the 2026 Fifa World Cup. In the 13th minute, Samukele Kabini missed a clear chance from an Oswin Appollis cross. Bryne Omondi kept Kenya level at 0-0 at the break with a string of crucial saves.
The breakthrough came in the 68th minute. A long kick from Williams found Appollis on the right wing. He beat Sylvester Owino, who failed to clear, and squared for Relebohile Mofokeng to finish unmarked.
South Africa’s coach, Pitso Mosimane, then introduced Iqraam Rayners and Teboho Mokoena for Lyle Foster and Sphephelo Sithole to add control, while McCarthy responded by resting Marcelo for Henry Ochieng, and Ouma for Harper.
Harambee Stars coach Benni McCarthy addresses the media at Nyayo National Stadium in Nairobi on November 16, 2026.
Photo credit: Chris Omollo | Nation Media Group
He later withdrew Olunga and Amos Wanjala for Mohamed Bajaber and Adam Wilson. Before Kenya’s defence had settled, Bafana doubled the lead in the 86th minute through Mofokeng again after another defensive lapse.
Kenya pulled one back two minutes later. Adam Wilson’s free-kick pass to Ryan Ogam, whose shot caused a scramble, and Bajaber got the final touch to make it 2-1. McCarthy said the difference over the two legs was clinical finishing.
“At times there is the lack of experience and also the lack of us not knowing what it’s like to participate in those big tournaments. These moments count because when you create chances against these teams you have to take them. The only difference was they were clinical and we were not, and the schoolboy mistakes that we made and they did not ,” he said.
He said his project is to build a team that reflects the Kenyan spirit, saying his conscience is clear because he knows what he is building ahead of Afcon 2027 on home soil.