The High Court has declared arbitrary towing charges imposed on motorists by traffic police unconstitutional, warning that officers and private breakdown operators cannot demand money without clear, publicly known rates and proper documentation.
Justice Lawrence Mugambi ruled that the charges are a violation of motorists’ constitutional protections.
Delivering a judgement in a case where a motorist, David Kimani, sued police for demanding Sh8,000 for towing his vehicle to Juja Police Station, without an invoice or explanation of how the amount was calculated, the judge said this was a violation of constitutional protections.
“It is hereby declared that the demand for payment of Sh8,000 as towing charges from the Petitioner purportedly pursuant Section 106 and 107 of the Traffic Act in a manner that is arbitrary, opaque and procedurally deficient offends the national values and principles of governance under Article 10 of the Constitution,” the judge stated.
The Milimani Law Courts in Nairobi.
Photo credit: Francis Nderitu | Nation Media Group
The judge said the demand made to Mr Kimani breached requirements for transparency, accountability and respect for property rights.
In his November 12 judgement, Justice Mugambi declared that the Sh8,000 charge, imposed without a clear basis or proper procedure, also violated rule of law.
The court also found that the demand offended the constitutional principles governing public service and amounted to arbitrary interference with the motorist’s property.
“Members of the public cannot be left at the whim of the police and private service providers to impose towing charges under Section 106 and 107 as they please,” the judge said.
He warned that allowing police officers and private operators to set charges without clear limits would expose motorists to arbitrary demands and seizure of their vehicles.
The case arose after Mr Waithera’s vehicle, registration number KCK 799K, was towed to Juja Police Station on December 25, 2025, following his arrest during a traffic operation.
Police said he appeared to be under the influence of alcohol and declined a request to undergo a breathalyser test. They also accused him of disobeying a police officer’s instructions.
According to the police, there was no other person to whom the vehicle could safely be handed over after his arrest. They therefore hired a local breakdown operator, Harrison Nzuki, to tow it to the station.
Mr Waithera was later released on a cash bail of Sh15,000 and taken to Thika Law Courts on December 29, 2025, over an alleged traffic offence.
When he returned to collect his vehicle on January 14, 2026, he was told to pay Sh8,000 in towing charges.
He challenged the demand, saying the police had not given him an invoice, a breakdown of the costs, details of the person to be paid or the legal basis for the amount.
The police maintained that the charge was based on standard Automobile Association (AA) rates and that the Traffic Act allows them to recover expenses incurred in removing vehicles.
But Mr Waithera argued that the police had not produced a contract with the towing operator, an invoice showing the actual expense or the AA schedule used to calculate the charge. He also questioned why rates set by a private motoring association should automatically bind members of the public.
Justice Mugambi agreed that although the Traffic Act gives police powers to remove and detain vehicles in certain circumstances, those powers do not give officers a free hand to impose charges.
He said motorists must be able to establish in advance how towing fees are determined and who is entitled to receive the money.
The judge acknowledged that requiring police to engage only pre-approved towing companies might be impractical because traffic incidents can happen anywhere and at any time. However, he said charges should be guided by a standard formula or fixed rates made public in advance.
“Public authority must not be used to facilitate private commercial advantage to the detriment of the public,” he said.
The court called for urgent changes to the law or policy guidelines to address how towing charges are calculated and collected during traffic enforcement operations.
It, however, did not rule that the towing of Mr Waithera’s vehicle was itself unlawful. The judge said the traffic court handling his pending case was better placed to determine whether the removal was justified and whether he should pay the towing costs.
He suspended the Sh8,000 demand until the traffic case is concluded. The traffic court will then determine whether the amount is payable and, if so, establish the proper sum based on evidence and justification from the police.
The vehicle had been released after Mr Waithera deposited the disputed Sh8,000 in court on January 30, 2026. The money will remain in court pending the traffic court’s decision.