A University of Nairobi postgraduate student who was turned away from an examination room despite having an examination card has lost a fourth attempt to compel the institution to allow her to sit her papers.
The High Court in Nairobi dismissed Beatrice Njeri Maina’s case, ruling that she had raised issues that had already been considered in an earlier dispute with the university.
Ms Maina, who is pursuing a Master of Medicine in Ear, Nose and Throat Surgery, said she was prevented from sitting examinations on August 17, 2026, without prior notice or an explanation.
She told the court that she had arrived at the examination room with the required documents, including her examination card, but the invigilator refused to give her the question papers and ordered her to leave.
She later checked the university’s examination portal and found that she had been registered for the papers.
The student wanted the university barred from denying her access to examinations except on grounds set out in its Student Code of Conduct. She also sought to have the lost academic time restored and Sh55,000 refunded for accommodation and other expenses.
However, the university maintained that she had not met the academic requirements to progress to the next stage of her course.
In an affidavit, Academic Registrar Humphrey Webuye said Ms Maina had failed to attain the required minimum mark of 50 per cent in the 2021/2022 academic year. Her last recorded progressive assessment was 45 per cent, he said.
The university further argued that registration on its student portal did not automatically qualify a student to sit examinations, as eligibility also depended on meeting academic, clinical and course progression requirements.
In a ruling delivered on November 16, Justice William Musyoka said the dispute had largely been dealt with in an earlier case involving the same student and the university.
In that case, Ms Maina had challenged her exclusion from examinations in 2020, 2022, 2023 and 2025, as well as her suspension from the programme.
The court had found that the university violated some of her rights and awarded her Sh10 million in compensation. However, it declined to order the institution to allow her to sit the examinations.
Justice Musyoka said the latest case was based on the same underlying disagreements over her academic progress and eligibility to sit examinations.
“All the issues raised were exhausted, considered and analysed,” the judge said, adding that Ms Maina was seeking another opportunity to obtain orders that had not been granted in the earlier case.
The judge also said the student had not demonstrated that she had met the academic requirements between the earlier judgment in July and the August examinations.
“She has not demonstrated that she was, at the material time, in compliance with the requirement that her grades would have reached the pass mark for progression to the next level,” he said.
Court upholds universities' academic discretion
The court observed that universities have room to enforce academic standards and that judges should not take over the running of academic programmes unless an institution is clearly shown to have violated its own rules.
Justice Musyoka dismissed the case but declined to order Ms Maina to pay the university's legal costs.
The judge noted that she was a student sponsored by her employer and was already facing difficulties with her studies. Ordering her to pay costs, he said, would add to her hardship.