The government has been given 90 days to identify and assess thousands of Nairobi residents who were evicted from their homes during the 2024 floods, with authorities directed to consider shelter, resettlement and other forms of assistance for those affected.
The Environment and Land Court said the government had a responsibility to protect people living in flood-prone areas, but this did not give authorities the right to demolish homes without following the required procedures.
Justice Charles Mbogo ruled that the Nairobi Rivers Commission and the Cabinet Secretary for Interior must consult representatives of the affected communities, establish who was displaced and assess their current circumstances.
The two agencies must also consider appropriate interventions, including temporary shelter, resettlement and other social protection measures, and file a report in court within 90 days from November 16.
The order followed a petition filed by 75 residents on behalf of about 3,000 people who said they were displaced when their homes were demolished in May and June 2024.
The affected settlements included Kamukunji, Kayole, Soweto, Korogocho, Kibera, Shimo la Tewa, Mukuru Kayaba and Mukuru Viwandani.
The demolitions followed heavy rains that caused flooding in several parts of the country, prompting the government to order residents living along rivers and other flood-prone areas to move to safer places.
However, the petitioners challenged the manner in which the evictions were carried out, arguing that they were left homeless after their houses were brought down without adequate notice or proper arrangements for relocation.
Government failed to follow eviction safeguards
In his judgment delivered on November 16, 2026, Justice Mbogo found that the authorities had failed to demonstrate compliance with the safeguards required when carrying out evictions.
A view of what was left after the floods that swept away houses built on riparian land in Mathare 4A, Nairobi on May 7, 2024.
Photo credit: Wilfred Nyangaresi | Nation Media Group
The judge said the government could not rely on the need to protect people from floods to justify ignoring the rights of those living in the affected areas.
“The government had a legitimate basis for protecting people from flood-prone riparian areas,” the court noted, while emphasising that the exercise had to be carried out within the law.
The court observed that protecting human life and the environment was an important government responsibility. However, authorities were still required to treat affected residents with dignity and respect their constitutional rights.
The judge stressed that people facing eviction must be given adequate notice and that the process must be properly authorised. Authorities must also take reasonable steps to protect their security and ensure vulnerable groups receive special consideration.
Those affected should also be given a reasonable opportunity to remove their belongings before their homes are demolished.
Buses stuck in floodwater at Kware area in Pipeline, Nairobi on May 1, 2024.
Photo credit: File Nation Media Group
Justice Mbogo further clarified that the absence of formal land ownership documents does not take away a person's constitutional protections, including the right to dignity and adequate housing.
However, the court distinguished between the protection of constitutional rights and ownership of land, noting that living on a piece of land does not automatically give an occupant legal ownership.
The ruling does not prevent the government from taking action to protect residents from dangerous locations. Instead, it requires authorities to balance that responsibility with the rights of people who stand to lose their homes.
The court also considered the petitioners' request for compensation over the loss of their houses and other property during the demolitions.
However, the judge declined to award general damages or compensation, saying the evidence presented was insufficient to establish the losses for which the residents sought payment.
This means the ruling does not provide an automatic financial payout to the thousands of people said to have been displaced. The immediate relief ordered by the court is an assessment of their circumstances and consideration of possible support.
The court also dismissed claims against Nairobi County and several other government agencies, finding that the petitioners had not provided sufficient evidence linking them to specific actions or failures that violated the residents' rights.
However, the court found that the Nairobi Rivers Commission, the Inspector General of Police and the Interior Cabinet Secretary had failed to demonstrate compliance with the required eviction safeguards.
The order for community consultation, assessment and a report within 90 days specifically applies to the Nairobi Rivers Commission and the Interior Cabinet Secretary.
The two agencies are expected to engage representatives of the affected communities, establish the circumstances of those displaced and consider interventions to address their needs, including temporary accommodation and possible resettlement.
The matter will be mentioned on May 3, 2027, when the court is expected to consider the progress made in implementing its orders.