Good behaviour in prison may demonstrate a convict’s rehabilitation and willingness to reform, but it does not automatically guarantee a reduced sentence or early release.
This is the caution the High Court has given to a convict serving a 15-year prison term over the robbery with violence that led to the killing of former Kilifi Deputy Governor Kenneth Kamto.
Kilifi Deputy Governor Kenneth Kamto addresses a Jubilee rally in Rabai on May 26, 2017. Investigations into his murder are ongoing.
Photo credit: File | Nation
The court observed that an inmate’s progress must be weighed against the seriousness of the offense, the interests of victims, the need to deter similar crimes and the protection of the public.
“I am not persuaded that Muasya Kiteme alias Mwa has demonstrated sufficient grounds to warrant substitution of the remaining custodial sentence with probation as recommended in the Sentence Review Report,” the judge said.
The judge held that the interests of justice and public protection required Kiteme to continue serving a custodial sentence, adding that a favourable probation assessment, although relevant, was not sufficient on its own to justify replacing imprisonment with a non-custodial term.
The court nevertheless acknowledged his progress in prison, noting that he had maintained family ties, demonstrated remorse and conducted himself well during his incarceration.
“These are commendable developments, and the court encourages him to maintain the same. Nevertheless, the offence for which Kiteme was convicted is robbery with violence, a grave offence that attracts serious penal consequences,” the judge said.
Kiteme was among six people initially arrested over the December 12, 2018 robbery at Mr Kamto’s residence in Nyali, Mombasa, during which the former deputy governor was shot dead.
He subsequently entered a plea bargain with the prosecution, admitted his involvement, and agreed to testify against his co-accused. He was convicted and sentenced to 15 years in prison.
His co-accused, Julius Gitonga and Joseph Amwayi Mukabana, were found guilty of robbery with violence and sentenced to 40 years and 30 years in prison, respectively. The sentences were to run concurrently.
The trial court found that Gitonga was the one who shot and killed Kamto, while Mukabana was directly involved in the robbery. In January 2025, the Shanzu court ruled that the gravity of the offenses and the need for deterrence and public protection made non-custodial sentences inappropriate.
From Left: Julius Gitonga M’Muguu, Joseph Amwayi Mukabana and Florence Mwanza Mbithe before Mombasa Senior Principal Magistrate Henry Nyakweba. Mr Gitonga and Mr Amwayi are co-accused alongside Mr Muasya Kiteme of fatally shooting former Kilifi Deputy Governor Kenneth Kamto on December 12, 2018.
Photo credit: File | Nation Media Group
The prosecution had relied on digital forensic evidence, mobile phone records, CCTV footage and witness testimony to link the suspects to the crime.
Investigators traced a mobile phone stolen from Kamto’s house help through its IMEI history and call data records, which helped establish connections between the suspects. Police also recovered a pistol believed to have been used in the killing, as well as mobile phones belonging to the deceased and his family.
The court heard evidence from 24 prosecution witnesses, including police officers, forensic experts and cybercrime specialists. Government pathologist Johansen Oduor testified that Kamto died from gunshot wounds that caused massive blood loss.
Two other suspects, Joseph Shoi Chege and Clementina Nerima, were acquitted in 2023 for lack of sufficient evidence.
Kiteme returned to court on June 25, 2024, seeking a review of his sentence. He argued that the trial court had failed to adequately account for the one year, five months and 13 days he spent in remand custody before conviction and sentencing.
He also told the court that he was remorseful, had reformed during his incarceration and deserved an opportunity to reintegrate into society.
A Sentence Review Report prepared by the Probation and Aftercare Service on October 6, 2026, described him as a reformed inmate who had maintained family ties and enjoyed the support of his wife, children, and extended family, who were willing to accommodate him upon release.
His family described him as responsible and hardworking, while local administrators reported that he had no other known criminal record and posed no security threat to the community.
Prison authorities also reported that he had demonstrated remorse, made positive progress in rehabilitation, and had no record of misconduct. The probation officer recommended that his remaining custodial sentence be substituted with three years of supervised probation in Mwingi.
However, the High Court found that the trial court had failed to demonstrate that the period Kiteme spent in pre-sentence custody had been taken into account when imposing the 15-year sentence, as required under Section 333(2) of the Criminal Procedure Code.
The judge ruled that merely recording the date an accused person was arrested or acknowledging that they had been in custody did not amount to compliance with the law.
The judge also said rehabilitation must be balanced against other sentencing objectives, noting that a favourable social inquiry report does not, on its own, justify reducing a sentence or replacing imprisonment with a non-custodial term.
The court therefore partly allowed the application, ordering that the one year, five months, and 13 days spent in remand custody be credited against his sentence. Prison authorities were directed to recalculate his remaining term, taking into account the credit and any applicable statutory remission.
However, the judge declined to substitute the remaining custodial sentence with three years of probation, meaning Kiteme will continue serving his prison term as recalculated. The court encouraged him to continue participating in rehabilitation programmes and maintain the positive conduct reported by prison authorities.