A court has allowed two more administrators of the estate of the late Josiah Mwangi Kariuki, former Nyandarua North MP, to join a land dispute in which the family is challenging the ownership of property said to belong to the estate.
The Environment and Land Court in Naivasha ruled that Anne Marie Wanjiku Kariuki and Jane Wangari Kariuki be added as the second and third plaintiffs in a case filed by Doris Nyambura Kariuki, also an administrator of the estate.
Justice Mary Oundo said the two had a direct interest because the outcome could determine whether the disputed property belongs to the estate.
All appointed administrators, the judge said, share responsibility for protecting the deceased’s assets for the benefit of beneficiaries.
“Because all appointed co-administrators bear joint statutory liability to account for and protect estate assets, a single co-administrator cannot unilaterally exclude co-administrators from participating in suits that decide the fate of core estate assets,” the judge ruled in her November 12 ruling.
The dispute involves Al Haiee Investment Limited, Family Bank of Kenya Limited, the Naivasha Land Registrar and the Attorney-General.
The estate claims that the property forms part of the assets left by the late Mr Kariuki, popularly known as JM Kariuki. He was murdered in 1975.
In affidavits supporting their application, Anne Marie and Jane said they were legal administrators alongside Doris.
They said they had recently learnt of the proceedings and wanted to help protect the estate and its beneficiaries.
They alleged that the title issued to Al Haiee Investment Limited had been irregularly, unlawfully or fraudulently obtained.
The late politician Josiah Mwangi (JM) Kariuki.
Photo credit: File | Nation Media Group
They further claimed that the property had been transferred or sold to some of the defendants without the knowledge or consent of all the administrators.
The two argued that leaving them out risked denying the estate and beneficiaries adequate representation. They said their participation was necessary for the court to resolve all questions concerning the property and would not prejudice the other parties.
Family Bank opposed the application in an affidavit sworn by its assistant manager for legal services, Joan Gachomba. It argued that Doris had adequately represented the estate since she filed the case in her capacity as an administrator.
The bank said the matter proceeded to hearing on March 23, 2026, when Doris testified and was cross-examined by the parties. It added that the hearing date had been agreed upon after several mentions over two years.
According to the bank, Anne Marie and Jane knew about the dispute but waited until after Doris had testified to seek to join the case. It described their application as an afterthought and argued that it could be an attempt to introduce new evidence and fill gaps exposed during Doris’s cross-examination.
It warned that allowing them to join at that stage could prolong the dispute, increase costs and reopen issues already addressed. It asked the court to dismiss the application or limit the two to supporting the existing case without reopening evidence.
Justice Oundo said a court could add a necessary party at any stage where that person’s presence would help resolve all questions in dispute. However, joining a case was not automatic; applicants had to show a clear interest and explain why their participation was necessary.
The judge found that the dispute affected the estate as a whole, not just the administrator who filed the case. Any decision on whether the property belonged to the estate or should be returned to it would affect all administrators and beneficiaries.
She rejected the argument that the application came too late because Doris had already testified, saying the start of a hearing did not automatically prevent the court from adding people whose presence was necessary for a complete decision.
The judge nevertheless acknowledged the bank’s concern that the new plaintiffs might use their admission to introduce fresh evidence or reopen the case. She said their participation had to be restricted to prevent unfairness, duplicated evidence and unnecessary delay.
“Denying joinder would pose a greater risk to the judgment’s finality than allowing them to be formally joined to the record,” she said.
The court allowed the application in part and directed that Anne Marie and Jane be added as the second and third plaintiffs in their capacity as co-administrators.
The three plaintiffs were directed to file and serve an amended plaint within 14 days from the date of ruling. The changes are limited to including the two new plaintiffs; they cannot alter the substance of the case or add new claims.
Doris’s testimony given on March 23, 2026, will remain intact. The two new plaintiffs must adopt it in full and cannot recall Doris or reopen her examination-in-chief.