On the e-procurement saga, the central question remains: did the government conduct adequate public participation before rolling out this reform? We must now wait for the judges to decide.
At stake is one of the most progressive governance reforms in recent years. Digitising procurement and eliminating paper transactions promises to inject transparency into government contracting.
Yet we now face a paradox. On one side lies the constitutional imperative of public participation, a national value entrenched in the 2010 Constitution. On the other is the equally pressing need to modernise procurement and safeguard public resources.
E-procurement is not just about how the government buys goods and services. It is part of a wider transformation of the public financial management ecosystem: the transition from cash-based to accrual accounting, the planned replacement of Integrated Finance Management Information System (Ifmis) with a modern enterprise resource planning (ERP) platform, and the introduction of a Single Treasury Account.
The question is not whether these reforms are necessary, but how to balance constitutional process with the urgency of modernisation. Without clear standards on what constitutes adequate participation in complex, technical reforms, every initiative risks derailment in court.
Kenya urgently needs a consensus on minimum requirements that must be met before the constitutional threshold for meaningful participation can be deemed satisfied. The current regime is vague. It does not define scope, content, or procedure. How many meetings are enough? Should participation be measured by numbers, opinion polls, or written submissions from experts and think tanks? Must every citizen be reached?
In the absence of such standards, judges have filled the void with their own subjective interpretations—often drifting into judicial wokeness. A case in point was in October last year when the High Court declared the Privatisation Act 2023 unconstitutional for want of adequate participation.
In that case, a 14-day public notice was published, and letters sent to stakeholders including PWC, KPMG and the Institute of Economic Affairs. Parliament’s Finance and Planning committee also invited submissions from the Nairobi Securities Exchange, the Privatisation Commission and the Public Procurement Oversight Authority. Still, the court ruled this was insufficient. One Court of Appeal judge went further, arguing that notices should have been published in Kiswahili.
In another ruling, a judge in Kiambu declared that participation “ought to be real, not illusory” and that parties conducting public participation must “attain both quantitative and qualitative standards”. Fine principles in theory, but when applied without clear statutory guidance, they set idealistic and unworkable thresholds.
The danger is that public participation becomes ritual. In democratic societies, officials must be held accountable for their actions, not for adherence to a vague, woke notion of participation. In today’s Kenya, the term has become a political hurrah word—invoked by leaders, activists and judges alike to claim legitimacy without necessarily fostering genuine citizen engagement. The result is that judges throw out reforms without considering the macro-economic consequences of their decisions.
The upshot is that public participation now functions as a judicial trump card, capable of vetoing executive and legislative action, while leaving the substance of reform untouched. Unless Kenya defines clear minimum standards for what “adequate” participation entails, reforms like e-procurement will continue to stall—not for lack of merit, but for failing an undefined constitutional test.
The government must not relent on implementing e-procurement. These are the kinds of reforms that will live long after President William Ruto has left the scene. But we must also not forget that e-procurement is only a first, small step. Why aren’t we debating a return to the old system where standard common-user items—fuel, vehicles, stationery, tyres, office furniture, carpets—were procured centrally?
That system, once managed by the defunct Supplies Branch in the Ministry of Public Works, made sense because the government leveraged bulk buying to secure goods and services at huge discounts.
Still, the most critical reform in the public finance management space remains the shift in government accounting—from cash accounting to accrual accounting. Currently, Kenya’s system is cash-based, recognising expenses only when payments are made, not when incurred, earned, or accrued. This does not allow complete, accurate and timely recording, classification and reporting of transactions across central and county governments.
And instead of a robust, functioning ERP, what we have is the misleadingly named Ifmis—a platform that is neither integrated nor capable of supporting modern financial management. In terms of public finance management, the government is like a plane flying blind. If you can’t measure it, you can’t manage it.