For generations, Kenyans have maintained a distinction between a house and a home, dramatically brought to the fore by the burial dispute over Silvano Melea Otieno’s remains.
A house is where one lives and leaves from to go to work. Home is where one belongs, where the ancestors are buried and where, eventually, one hopes to return. That distinction is becoming less useful to an increasing number of Kenyans. More people are born, raised and grow old in towns, with no ancestral plot to retire to.
There is a housing problem, certainly. But it is also an old labour problem that Kenya has never quite resolved.
Luise White’s book, The Comforts of Home: Prostitution in Colonial Nairobi, offers a window into its origins. The colonial economy depended on African labour without accepting responsibility for the conditions in which that labour lived. African women, including prostitutes, created their own domestic arrangements and survival economies in a city that wanted their labour but was unwilling to make room for their lives.
The countryside subsidised the city by absorbing the costs of housing, family life and social reproduction that employers and the colonial state refused to bear. This contributed to the growth of informal settlements.
Independence did not dismantle it. Millions of Kenyans still work in towns where their labour is indispensable but their incomes cannot guarantee decent accommodation. This is the background against which the affordable housing programme needs to be examined.
The opening of the Pioneer Affordable Housing Estate in Eldoret provides a useful starting point. It is a substantial development, intended to create more than an apartment complex through the provision of commercial and community facilities.
But building houses and providing housing are two different endeavours. An estate needs more than buildings. Residents need water, sanitation, security, transport, schools and access to employment. Who manages the estate after the construction crews leave? Who maintains the common facilities, and at what cost to residents? These are questions of estate management, not construction.
Yet, Kenya is not starting from a blank slate. The National Housing Corporation (NHC), established in 1953, has a history of housing development, property management and estate administration. The Kenya National Slum Upgrading Programme and the Kenya Informal Settlements Improvement Project have also demonstrated that improving housing does not always require building new houses. Roads, drainage, water, sanitation, lighting and security of tenure can transform existing settlements without displacing their residents.
The recent appointment of John Washington Agutu as NHC’s acting chief executive brings the corporation’s role into focus. [Disclosure: I have known Agutu since our school days, when he was my deputy school captain.] His academic training in land economics and housing administration, and his professional experience in estate management, housing development, financing and property valuation, reflect a longstanding interest in providing housing for urban populations. He has previously served as NHC’s general manager in charge of estate management.
Kenya needs a national housing institution capable of looking beyond construction targets to the economics of urban settlement: land prices, household incomes, rental markets, housing finance and estate management. It should work with county governments, developers, cooperatives and communities to expand the range of housing available to different income groups.
The affordable housing programme has concentrated political and financial attention on home ownership. Ownership is, however, not the only route to secure housing. Young people entering the labour market may not want mortgages.
Workers with irregular incomes may not qualify for tenant-purchase arrangements. Others need decent rental accommodation, serviced plots or improvements to existing settlements. A national housing institution must respond to these different needs rather than assume that every Kenyan aspires to own an apartment in a high-rise estate.
There is also an unsettled institutional question: What should be the relationship between NHC’s accumulated experience, the Affordable Housing Board’s responsibilities and the wider housing programme? These institutions should complement one another, not compete for responsibility.
The president has made affordable housing the signature enterprise of his administration. But Kenya’s housing policy cannot begin and end with one presidency. NHC’s institutional history and the experience accumulated by previous administrations should be assets to the current programme, not casualties of presidential branding.
The real test of affordable housing is whether Kenya develops a lasting capacity to house its growing urban population, whether workers can afford to live in the cities they sustain, and whether the homes delivered today remain decent places to live tomorrow.
The writer is a board member of KHRC and writes in his individual capacity. @kwamchetsi; [email protected] .