Ms Margaret Wanja Muthui, formerly a deputy director at the Kenya Rural Roads Authority (Kerra), is battling it out against the EACC, which wants her to refund the salaries and allowances she earned during her 14 years at the roads agency.
Three years earlier, she been ordered to surrender apartments and land worth at least Sh279 million and more than Sh95 million in bank accounts to the State at the end of a money laundering case.
The salary refund case is ongoing at the High Court. In the case, the EACC is seeking to recover payments made to Ms Muthui between October 2009 and May 2023, arguing that she secured employment and subsequent promotions using a forged Bachelor of Science degree in Computer Science purportedly issued by Jomo Kenyatta University of Agriculture and Technology (JKUAT).
The commission wants the court to declare her employment as a procurement officer and subsequent appointment as procurement manager unlawful, saying the positions were obtained through fraud.
The commission says in court documents that it is seeking “a declaration that Ms Muthui’s employment as a procurement officer and thereafter procurement manager by Kerra was fraudulent, illegal and therefore null and void ab initio as it was secured through fraud”.
The Milimani Law Courts in Nairobi.
Photo credit: Francis Nderitu | Nation Media Group
According to the suit, Ms Muthui applied for the position of procurement officer in 2009, indicating in her curriculum vitae that she had obtained a Computer Science degree from JKUAT in 2004.
She was hired in October that year and rose through the ranks to become senior procurement officer before being appointed acting procurement manager in September 2011.
In October 2013, she applied for the substantive procurement manager position, listing a Master’s degree in Procurement and Logistics and a Bachelor’s degree in Computer Science, both purportedly from JKUAT. The position was later renamed deputy director in charge of supply chain management.
However, EACC claims that its investigations established that JKUAT had never issued the disputed undergraduate degree.
Ms Muthui was suspended in March 2023. She subsequently denied holding the Computer Science degree, claiming she had graduated from Kenya Methodist University (Kemu) with a Bachelor of Business Administration in Procurement and Supply Chain Management in July 2008.
She allegedly presented a police abstract reporting the loss of her certificate and a letter purportedly signed by Kemu Registrar of Academic Affairs, Dr Lucy Ikiara, confirming her graduation.
But EACC says investigations established that she had never been a student at the university and that the purported certificate was not genuine.
Although her Master’s degree from JKUAT was genuine, the university reportedly nullified it in March 2023 after establishing that the undergraduate qualification she had used to gain admission was forged.
“It is therefore evident that through presentation of a forged Bachelor of Science Degree from JKUAT, the Defendant was fraudulently able to be employed and paid the aforesaid salaries and allowances,” EACC says.
The latest recovery suit stems from the decision that saw her lose numerous assets through a court order.
The decision, issued in 2023 by Justice Esther Maina, ordered the forfeiture to the State of properties and funds linked to Ms Muthui. That case had been filed by the Assets Recovery Agency (ARA).
Ms Muthui and other parties named in the case have appealed against the decision, with the matter pending hearing.
The properties that the forfeiture order touched on include 11 apartments in Kileleshwa, bought for Sh264 million in cash between July and September 2019, 12 units in Ruaka acquired for Sh15 million, a house in Nairobi and land in Riruta, Dagoretti.
The court also ordered the forfeiture of more than Sh95 million held in three bank accounts, agreeing with ARA that the assets were proceeds of crime acquired through proxies to conceal their ownership and source of funds.
Ms Muthui’s troubles had earlier attracted political attention after President William Ruto criticised her for successfully challenging her transfer from Kerra in 2019 when he was the Deputy President. Ms Muthui had argued that she was being moved from procurement, where she had risen through the ranks, to the Office of Performance Management and Coordination under the Presidency, despite lacking expertise in the new role.
She also claimed the transfer followed her questioning of a tender she believed had been overpriced by Sh1 billion.