Kiambu Nyakinyua Farmers Company Limited has lost a bid to stop a Naivasha land dispute from proceeding as it awaits the outcome of a separate court battle over its board of directors.
The Environment and Land Court dismissed an application by the company and its director, Michael Kamore Kigotho, to suspend the case involving a disputed parcel of land in Kijabe, until the leadership dispute is resolved.
Justice Mary Oundo ruled that the disagreement over the company’s directors did not prevent the land case from proceeding, noting that the company still had recognised directors and was actively participating in the proceedings through lawyers.
The magistrate’s court in Naivasha is now free to hear the dispute, on a priority basis.
The case was filed by Peter Kinyanjui Kiarie, who says he bought the land in 1985 but has been kept out of it since May 2022. He accuses parties in the dispute of fraudulently transferring the property and wants the contested title cancelled and the land registered in his name.
Nyakinyua Farmers, which is involved in the case as a third party, and Mr Kigotho had asked the Environment and Land Court to stop the proceedings pending the outcome of a separate High Court case over changes to the company’s list of directors.
They argued that the company had undergone an irregular change of leadership, creating uncertainty over who was authorised to represent it in court.
Their lawyer told the court that the High Court had issued orders stopping the registration of the contested changes to the company’s records. He argued that the leadership dispute had to be resolved first to establish who could properly give instructions to lawyers and defend the company’s interests in the land case.
The applicants also said the two cases were scheduled for July 6, 2026, and that allowing the land trial to proceed before the leadership dispute was resolved could prejudice the company.
But Mr Kiarie opposed the application, arguing that the two cases dealt with different issues and involved different parties.
He told the court that the High Court case concerned the company’s internal leadership, while the Naivasha land case was about alleged fraud in the transfer of a specific property.
He further argued that the company was not without directors because the High Court’s orders had preserved the board that existed before the disputed changes were made in September 2024.
The Naivasha Law Court. The magistrate’s court in Naivasha is now free to hear the dispute, on a priority basis.
Photo credit: File | Nation
The company had also continued to participate in the land proceedings through lawyers, filed applications and pursued the appeal, undermining its claim that it could not properly defend itself, he said.
Mr Kiarie warned that further delays would unfairly prolong his struggle to recover the land, which he said he had purchased more than four decades ago.
He told the court that he had been locked out of the property since May 2022 and that keeping the case on hold would leave the disputed title exposed to possible sale, subdivision or use as security for a loan.
In her ruling delivered on November 12, Justice Oundo said the court had to consider whether the appeal raised a genuine issue worth examining, whether proceeding with the trial would undermine the appeal and which party would suffer greater injustice from further delays.
The judge found that the company’s argument that it had no legitimate directors was contradicted by the documents it had presented.
She said a High Court order issued on November 17, 2024, had stopped the changes made to the company’s records in September that year. This meant the previous board remained in office while the leadership dispute was being resolved.
The company’s own records also identified Mr Kigotho as one of the recognised directors, the judge noted.
“There is, therefore, no operational or legal vacuum within the 1st Appellant,” she said.
Kiambu Nyakinyua Farmers Company lost a bid to stop a Naivasha land dispute from proceeding.
Photo credit: Shutterstock
Justice Oundo also questioned how the company could claim that it was unable to defend itself in the land case while at the same time instructing lawyers, filing applications in the magistrate’s court, lodging an appeal and pursuing the application before her.
The High Court matter concerns the validity of changes to the company’s leadership records, while the Naivasha land case is about whether the 2022 transfer of the disputed property was fraudulent.
She said the land trial did not require the magistrate to decide who the legitimate directors of Nyakinyua Farmers were.
The company’s historical land records, including share certificates, registers and allocation records, could also be obtained through ordinary court procedures without stopping the trial, she added.
The applicants had relied on previous decisions in other land cases involving the company, where proceedings were suspended pending resolution of the leadership dispute.
But Justice Oundo said those cases had different circumstances. In the present dispute, the existing High Court orders had preserved the previous board, the company was participating in the case and its role was limited to that of a third party.
The judge therefore found that the appeal did not raise strong enough grounds to justify stopping the trial.
She also rejected the argument that allowing the case to proceed would make the appeal meaningless, noting that the company would still be able to challenge the final decision if it was dissatisfied.
On the question of fairness, Justice Oundo said the interests of justice required the land dispute to be resolved without further unnecessary delay.
She observed that Mr Kiarie claimed an interest in the property dating back to 1985 and had allegedly been denied possession for more than four years.
“Indefinitely halting the trial court proceedings while corporate factions fight over company directorship in separate judicial review proceedings imposes severe, uncompensated prejudice on the 1st Respondent,” the judge said.
She dismissed the application, lifted the temporary order that had stopped the magistrate’s court proceedings and directed that the land case proceed on a priority basis.