2024 was annus horribilis for the Kenya Kwanza administration. The regime was tested beyond capacity with the Gen-Z protests that rocked the country in June and July. The response from the government has been marked by abductions, deaths and maiming of Gen-Zs in particular – the worst of it being the discovery of bodies of young women at a dumpsite in Kware , Nairobi.
The government has been steadfast in its denial of being involved in the abductions and deaths of dissidents. With police and a secret killer squad blamed for the menace, who reportedly operate with the blessings from the Executive, it is difficult for the government to shake off such serious allegations.
Instead of rethinking and finding a more lawful means to deal with dissidents, it continues to operate with impunity by furthering the kidnappings and murders. The recent disappearance of the four young activists, among them cartoonists, does not bode very well for the government.
The kidnappings have led to calls for the head of the National Police Service to resign. I am not sure asking the Inspector-General of Police to quit is the most effective way of addressing the problem. Without holding those in government to account, especially the President and the Interior Cabinet Secretary, getting junior staff to resign is an exercise in futility.
There are two arguments in conflict. One is where the government is accused of being behind the abductions and killings of dissidents. The other is denial by the same government. The two positions do not favour the government nor absolve it of accountability and duty of care towards citizens.
If, indeed, allegations of state machinery being behind the abductions are true and can be proved, then the government is culpable and those in charge of security must be legally held to account. If the government is not involved in the kidnappings and they go on unabatedly, then authorities have failed in their duty of care to the citizens and must be held to account for omission.
Whichever way Kenya looks at abductions and extra-judicial killings, the buck still stops with the government. Issuing denials and statements galore does not resolve an issue that is almost getting out of hand. The government has clearly not shown commitment to end the kidnappings and murders of perceived dissidents. Summary dismissal or punishment of any kind towards the dissidents, aside from that meted by courts, amounts to impunity and violation of rights.
As a result, officials in charge of protecting Kenyans are culpable for such heinous crimes. Due process of the law should not be cherry-picked but be there for the benefit of all lawbreakers – dissident or not. The government, as an aggrieved party, has as much right to be heard in court as any other entity. Why would it fail to turn to the courts and instead resort to underhand tactics of abducting and killing dissidents?
If it is true that the abductions and killings are sanctioned by the state, then the government is behaving as police, prosecutor and judge. If indeed the hands of those in power are clean as they say, they still owe it to Kenyans to reassure them of their safety and that of their property. They must mean what they say and show through action.
The more allegations of abductions and murders of Kenyans swirl around the government, the more trust it loses. It cannot get back the trust of the citizens by threats, intimidation and kidnapping of their children.
Trust is like virginity, they say. You lose it once and that is it. The credibility of the government is wanting due to the way it is handling alternative voices. There will always be opposition to the government. However, if that opposition is universal and voters speak with one voice against the government of the day – with valid reasons – then it is important for the government to work towards re-establishing trust rather than burn the bridge with voters.
As we edge towards 2025, it would be imperative to follow the path of accountability than just giving officials a slap on the wrist following serious human rights violations. Kenya needs to turn a new leaf in 2025 and beyond by embracing the rule of law and due process. We are, unfortunately, led by anarchists. That is detrimental to societal values of unity, love and peace that leaders vacuously sing about.
There is a need, therefore, to repair the relationship between the government and the citizens. There is need too for more stability in the future. Protests and online vitriol against the government is the public showing its displeasure with the status quo.
For citizens to get to the point of wishing their leaders dead, it means they have been pushed too far to the wall. The government needs to take criticism positively and reach out to citizens to mend fences than turn to violence and intimidation. You can’t rule over people by fear! It is time to rebuild trust between the people and the government.