Anti-Counterfeit Authority boss Josphat Kabeabea has suffered a legal setback after the High Court declined to stop the Directorate of Criminal Investigations (DCI) from investigating and prosecuting him over an alleged Sh14 million land fraud.
The court ruled that granting the orders he sought would effectively shield him from investigations and possible criminal liability despite apparent and reasonable grounds for the complaints against him.
“That would result in violation of the rights of the complainants to equal treatment and protection by the law and access to justice. I see no other plausible orders except dismissal of the petition for lack of merits,” the court said in a ruling delivered on November 13.
The judge found that the former legislator had failed to demonstrate that the investigations or decision to prosecute him were unlawful, driven by improper motives, or amounted to an abuse of the criminal justice process.
The Milimani Law Courts in Nairobi.
Photo credit: Francis Nderitu | Nation Media Group
Five complainants in the case claim to have lost a combined Sh14,096,950 in disputed land transactions.
Mr Kabeabea filed the petition in November 2025, seeking protection against what he described as threatened unlawful arrest, harassment and prosecution over transactions involving Diamond Property Merchants Limited.
He wanted the court to declare that his threatened arrest and detention were arbitrary, illegal and a violation of his constitutional rights. He also sought permanent orders barring the DCI and the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (ODPP) from arresting, charging or prosecuting him.
In his petition, Mr Kabeabea said he had previously served as a non-executive director of Diamond Property Merchants Limited, a company involved in land subdivision and sales.
He accused investigators of persistently threatening and harassing him despite his cooperation and compliance with their summons, claiming the renewed investigations were intended to intimidate, embarrass and damage his reputation.
He also cited a separate bribery case before the Milimani Anti-Corruption Court, in which he pleaded not guilty and was released on cash bail in November 2025.
The police, however, maintained that the investigations arose from complaints by five buyers who accused the company of failing to transfer land titles and undertake promised developments after receiving payment under a project known as Bethany Phase Three.
According to an affidavit by Corporal Allan Senyeli, the project involved parcels Kajiado/Ildamat/1148, 1149 and 1150. The first complaints were lodged with the DCI on August 13, 2020, by Justus Muithya Kivindyo and other purchasers.
The officer said Mr Kabeabea was a director when the transactions took place and was recommended for prosecution after investigations. The DPP directed on July 8, 2024, that he be charged, prompting police to issue summons requiring him to appear before investigators.
Corporal Senyeli claimed that Mr Kabeabea failed to honour the summons, leading to his prosecution alongside two others at the Kajiado Chief Magistrate's Court in a case filed in 2025.
They face charges of conspiracy to defraud and obtaining money by false pretences. Mr Kabeabea failed to appear for plea-taking, prompting the court to issue warrants of arrest on December 17, 2025.
The five complainants allegedly lost Sh14,096,950. Phoebe Njoki accounted for the largest amount, Sh10,610,950, while Justus Muithya Kivindyo and Joseph Njoroge each lost Sh1,003,000. Musa Kinyanjui Thondu and Maryanne Nyambura each claim to have lost Sh740,000.
Corporal Senyeli denied that investigators had visited Mr Kabeabea's home or office to harass him, maintaining that police were discharging their investigative mandate and that the DPP had independently assessed the evidence before directing prosecution.
The court found that the complaints went beyond a simple failure to transfer land titles, noting allegations that some parcels had been fraudulently sold to other buyers without the purchasers' consent.
It held that the existence of a civil dispute did not bar criminal proceedings based on the same facts, citing Section 193A of the Criminal Procedure Code.
“The materials exhibited by the respondents in their replying affidavit show more than an unspecified threat to arrest someone for failing to pay a debt,” the judge said, adding that investigators were entitled to examine the complaints.
The court also rejected claims that the prosecution was politically motivated or intended to recover private debts, finding no evidence to support either allegation.
“Other than the names of the complainants, no details of their social or economic engagements have been disclosed to connect their conduct to politics or interests other than pursuit of a legitimate cause of action,” the judge said.
The court further found that Mr Kabeabea had not demonstrated harassment, threats or a violation of his constitutional rights, including any breach of the DPP's obligations under Article 157(11) of the Constitution.
It ruled that the issues he had raised could be addressed before the trial court as part of his defense.