A few bad apples: This has been the defensive stock response whenever police criminality and impunity has reared its head over the years.
The fatal shooting of 19-year-old Joshua Steven in Mwiki, Kasarani, on the outskirts of the capital city over the weekend just days after police shot and critically injured three youth during demonstrations to protest against the torture and murder of Albert Ojwang’ in custody underlines a painful truth: Nobody can save the Kenya Police.
Neither reform nor resignation; penance nor prosecution; and not dismissal or lustration can save Kenya’s police. They have all been tried before and they have spectacularly failed each time. Top police bosses have been forced to resign. Some have been dismissed. A few are serving time for murder. Instead of these being an example that models normal behaviour, they are the outliers: different monkeys, same forest.
Over the past 20 years, some 10 reports have laid out in great detail measures that Kenya needed to undertake to turn around its police into a user-friendly public service. Each of them is buried in the cemetery of ignominy.
In the wake of the scandal of Albert Ojwang’s torture and murder in police custody , an intelligent service would have seen that it was time to act contrite. One mask hawker was brutalised before being shot in the head as the cameras rolled. Police violence has been relentless.
Last year alone, the Missing Voices coalition documented a total 159 cases of extrajudicial killings and enforced disappearances. Of the 159 cases, 104 were incidents of police-related killings, while 55 were enforced disappearances. The year before, the Independent Medico-Legal Unit documented 67 deaths in cost-of-living protests.
There has been no accountability conversation in the police over these outrages, let alone discussions about reforms because the high command believes that they run a stellar service.
The boldest attempts to reform the police through vetting and lustration after the promulgation of the Constitution of Kenya, 2010, came a cropper when those entrenched in the service literally purchased for themselves a new lease of life.
Attempts to offer the police constitutional and legal protection from political interference have been countered with surrender to the Executive and servicing those who can pay. Less than two years ago, a task force led by Chief Justice David Maraga on the terms of service laid the blame for the malaise at the doorstep of incompetent leadership, but the illness is much deeper.
Events in the past year have left little doubt that the police service is a criminal enterprise unwittingly funded by the public purse. The police present all the pathologies of a failing institution. They have moved from hiring out firearms for robberies to subcontracting criminal gangs to intimidate citizens.
Trans Nzoia Governor George Natembeya intimated that Ojwang’s death was probably a kindness that spared him the indignities that he might have suffered in custody. He revealed that in his experience of dealing with the police, it was routine for officers to use criminals to perpetrate sexual violence and other indignities against people in custody.
Democratic control of the security services means that civilians are the bosses. The posture of the police towards the public inverts that relationship, and it needs an urgent return to factory settings. The police enjoy their alienation from the public they are meant to serve in order to use the latter as kiosks for collecting rents. On the roads, they are masters of the shakedown.
Stripped of the uniform, rank, badge and firearm, the ordinary police officer is a normal human being who has a family and sings in the church choir. But behind the peaked cap, swagger stick in hand, and protection of the law, he is an automaton programmed to perform mindless cruelty and defend it.
Police have over the years received pay rises, improved terms of service, better housing, and health insurance — as they should— sometimes at the expense of other essential services such as nursing and teaching. Instead of rendering grateful service, members of the police service have stretched the public patience with whataboutisms around the occupational hazards they face.
Anthony O’Rourke, writing in the Columbia Law Review, opines that police are often too insulated from democratic oversight to be reformed. Typically, institutions that perform poorly are replaced — as has happened with the electoral management body in Kenya.
The problem with incremental police reforms has not been their content, but the policing institutions that they sought to reform. These institutions have created the structural obstacles — ranging from political deadlock, to organised resistance, and cultural hostility — that block change.
The solution to immovable obstacles is disbandment. Disbanding is not abolition, and is not an end in itself, but a mechanism for achieving greater aims by removing the structural obstacles that frustrate change.
Consider the resistance that has been mounted against the recommendations in the report of the Commission on the Post-Election Violence, chaired by Justice Philip Waki; then the Taskforce on Police Reform chaired by Justice Philip Ransley, and subsequently by the Police Reform Implementation Committee chaired by Titus Naikuni. There is a genie at Vigilance House that finds a way to give short shrift to proposals for change.
For the police to become a service that responds to the people, Vigilance House and the National Police Service need to be urgently disbanded, policing devolved to the counties and the entire edifice brought down to be replaced by people’s constabularies that recruit locally and are accountable to those they serve.
There will always be a question about ‘national security’, but the answer is obvious -- even State House is under the jurisdiction of a locational chief.
The writer is a member of the KHRC board and writes in his individual capacity. @kwamchetsi; [email protected]