The Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission (IEBC) has warned that the prolonged vacancy in its chief executive’s office could affect preparations for the August 2027 General Election, as it fights a court case that has halted the recruitment process.
The commission wants the Employment and Labour Relations Court in Malindi to lift orders stopping interviews, saying the position is central to running the Secretariat and coordinating its work.
In a replying affidavit, IEBC Director of Legal Services Chrispine Owiye says the Commission Secretary and chief executive is the accounting officer, custodian of commission records and head of the Secretariat. The Secretary executes commission decisions and supervises employees.
“The continued absence of a substantive Secretary affects the Commission’s ability to discharge these critical functions and has implications for its preparedness for the forthcoming General Election,” Mr Owiye says.
IEBC seeks to have Thomas Kennedy Balala’s petition struck out. The commission’s lawyer Charles Mwongela argues that the Labour Court lacks jurisdiction to handle the case since there is no employer-employee relationship between the petitioner and IEBC.
He adds that a related challenge over the same recruitment is pending before the High Court in Nairobi.
Lawyer Mwongela says Section 10 of the IEBC Act requires the commission to appoint the Secretary through an open, transparent and competitive process. The law also places responsibility for managing the Secretariat on the officeholder and facilitating the commission’s constitutional mandate.
The legal dispute followed IEBC’s advertisement of the vacancy on July 28, 2026. The application period closed on August 11, with the commission receiving 304 applications before shortlisting nine candidates for interviews scheduled for November 12 and 13.
Justice Jorum Abuodha issued interim orders on November 5, stopping the interviews and restraining a final appointment under the challenged shortlist.
The case questions the openness and transparency of the shortlisting process, including the involvement of KPMG Advisory Services Limited in the recruitment exercise. IEBC’s lawyer says the consultancy firm provided support but did not take over statutory decision-making.
Mr Mwongela says applications were sent to an email address at KPMG. The firm logged applicant details and conducted preliminary checks against the advertisement.
“The first interested party did not possess, and the Commission did not cede or delegate to it, any discretionary evaluation, veto or independent shortlisting authority,” he says.
Mr Mwongela says IEBC’s Selection Panel approved the shortlist and retained responsibility for choosing the successful candidate. He says the commission has offered to produce the KPMG engagement document, terms of reference, scoring matrix, evaluation criteria and minutes approving the shortlist.
The petition also raises questions about diversity, but IEBC says its advertisement encouraged women, young people, persons with disabilities and members of marginalised and minority communities to apply. It adds that it did not ask applicants to declare those characteristics.
IEBC says it therefore lacks demographic information for all 304 applicants. It has offered to provide the information that can be established from its records, while seeking permission to redact personal and sensitive data.
On citizenship, IEBC says each of the nine shortlisted candidates was checked against the statutory requirements and verified as Kenyan. It says a name cannot establish nationality and no shortlisted candidate has been identified as non-Kenyan.
Lawyer Mwongela, appearing for IEBC alongside Jotham Arwa, said the commission wanted its preliminary objection heard first because it challenged the court’s authority to determine the case.
IEBC also opposed an application by National Liberal Party leader Augustus Kyalo Muli to join the Malindi case as an interested party. IEBC says his similar claims can be pursued in the Nairobi petition, which has since been suspended pending the Malindi proceedings.
IEBC does not oppose preserving records or producing documents, subject to privacy safeguards. It has asked for seven days to file a supplementary affidavit with the documents.
The case is set for hearing on December 8, 2026. The interim orders remain in force.