Even as Members of Parliament offered major relief to patients by outlawing the detention of patients or bodies by health facilities, there was major division in the House over whether the new law would disadvantage hospitals.
At least five key issues emerged during the debate on the Health (Amendment) Bill, 2024, which seeks to outlaw the detention of patients and bodies over unpaid medical bills.
While the majority of MPs supported the Bill, some raised questions that the Bill is skewed, as it focuses more on the rights of patients and neglects the needs of hospitals to continue operating.
“A person in charge of a health facility shall not detain permit or cause the detention of a patient who has been discharged or the body of a deceased on grounds of non-payment whether in part of in full of the hospital bills or medical expenses,” reads the Bill sponsored by Kirinyaga Woman Representative Njeri Maina.
The Bill imposes a fine of Sh2 million upon conviction on hospital managers in both public and private hospitals if they detain a patient or the body of a deceased person.
The debate was triggered by Kilifi North MP Owen Baya, who pointed out that a section that places a caveat on patients who will be released before paying the medical bill in full negates the main objective of the bill.
The Bill places a caveat that patients who, at the time of admission, choose to be admitted to a private or semi-private room in any facility will have to pay their medical bills before a body or patient can be discharged.
National Assembly Health Committee Chairperson James Nyikal raised concern that there is a possibility of people taking advantage of the new law.
“You can’t get into a facility then choose that I want to go to a private room or bed and then at the end of it you say you’re unable to pay while you had an opportunity to be taken to a general ward where the cost is lower,” Dr Nyikal said.
“As much as we support people, we must look at people who take advantage of the provision of the law. The law can be taken advantage of. People who are needy will actually not have this problem. The people who will give us problems are those who know they can but they know the law is there and will say, why can’t I go to the best facility after all somebody will pay,” he added.
Kangundo MP Fabian Kyule warned his colleagues that the House cannot make rules that focus on the patient and not hospitals.
“We cannot just say, the person should not pay the bill, before this Bill came, there was medicine that was used, and there was somebody that put his energy there. Let’s avoid scenarios where we are going to kill investments. This law must take care of both sides,the patients and the hospitals,” Mr Kyule said.
Nyatike MP Tom Odege also pointed out that the law should serve both the hospital and the patient and the hospital.
“Health is a serious area of investment that is also prone to exploitation. As a trained health practitioner, we have to be fair to both the patient and the hospital,” Mr Odege said.
Tigania West MP John Mutunga said the laws made must encourage private hospitals, saying those who deliberately decide to seek treatment in a private facility should pay.
“We need to encourage private investments. Not every patient is in critical condition some of them can speak for themselves, we must be careful on the context at which the patient got into a hospital,” Dr Mutunga said.
In a bid to balance the equation, Magarini MP Harrison Kombe said if a hospital has to detain a patient or body, then there should be extra charges
The position was supported by Baya, who said detaining a patient or body amounts to double punishment.
“In the event you (hospital) decide to detain someone, then the original Bill should remain constant because it is double punishment, you’re punishing me for not paying and you’re also adding the cost of detention for me to pay-this is double jeopardy,” Mr Baya said.
“If a hospital detained a person for one month for Sh100,000 bill then even after that one month, the bill should just be 100,000 because detaining a patient or body, then when bill becomes 500k, you take a title deed of the patient should not be encouraged,” he added.
There were also emerging questions on how to treat a patient who needs isolation in a private room, whether he should pay or be discharged and pay later.
Some lawmakers also raised fears that upon coming into law, private hospitals risk changing all their general wards into private ones so that those admitted can pay.
There are also emerging questions on the enforceability of the promissory note introduced in the new Bill by MPs.
The promissory note is a legal tool that seeks to help hospitals recover their treatment costs; relatives of the patient or the deceased will have to sign a promissory note with the respective health facility on how they are going to settle the bill.
The promissory note will be a legally binding document for the person releasing the body from the hospital, who will undertake to make payment so that the hospital can recover its costs.
It will indicate the duration and modalities on how the discharged patient or relatives of the deceased will clear the outstanding medical bills incurred during treatment, and the signature of the person releasing a patient or body.
“There have arguments that expenses have been incurred in taking care of this person whether they die or they are discharged and therefore arrangements should be made for the people who have been taking care of them to recover their cost and that is why we have brought in the issue of promissory note,” Dr Nyikal said.
Hospitals will have the power to enforce the implementation of the promissory note in a court of law.
The issues, the lawmakers said, will be made clearer in the regulations once the Bill is assented to by the President.