County governments have suffered a major setback after the Court of Appeal ruled that they have no automatic constitutional right to a direct share of the Roads Maintenance Levy Fund (RMLF).
The appellate court overturned key findings by the High Court, which had declared unconstitutional Parliament’s decision to exclude counties from the fund, saying the Constitution does not prescribe any fixed proportion of the levy for the devolved units.
The judges, however, faulted Parliament for failing to observe constitutional requirements of consultation and cooperation when making decisions affecting the financing of county road maintenance.
“We, accordingly, find that county governments have no constitutional entitlement to direct allocations from the RMLF, whether at 15 per cent of its proceeds or at any other fixed proportion,” the court said.
The judges said the Constitution allows county-road maintenance to be financed through the equitable share, additional conditional or unconditional allocations, or other lawful arrangements. It does not make direct allocations from the levy the only or mandatory funding mechanism.
They agreed with the High Court that county-road maintenance is a constitutional function requiring adequate financial support but disagreed that this necessarily entitled counties to direct payments from the RMLF.
“The Constitution protects the capacity of county governments to perform their functions; it does not constitutionalise any particular financing instrument. The obligation to provide adequate support cannot be equated with an entitlement to a specified source of revenue,” the judges said.
The dispute arose after the National Assembly, through decisions made on September 28, 2023, and August 13, 2024, excluded county governments from proposed allocations from the RMLF.
The Council of Governors (CoG), alongside Issa Elanyi Chamao, Patrick Ekirapa, Paul Kirui and International Legal Consultancy Group, challenged the decisions, arguing that they undermined devolution and were made without adequate consultation, public participation or the involvement of the Senate.
The petitioners had sought to secure county governments a share of the levy, with the CoG and Senate committees pushing for direct allocations of between 42 and 49 per cent.
They argued that counties were constitutionally responsible for maintaining county roads and could not be denied funding from a levy specifically established to support road maintenance.
In June last year, the High Court ruled that Parliament's decision to remove counties as beneficiaries of the Sh10.5 billion fund for the 2024/2025 financial year was unconstitutional.
Justice Lawrence Mugambi held that Parliament could not appropriate all revenue collected nationally for road maintenance to national agencies while ignoring county governments' constitutional responsibilities.
The High Court also declared provisions of the Kenya Roads Act and Kenya Roads Board Act unconstitutional, arguing that they failed to recognise counties as key players in road maintenance.
The Court of Appeal, however, set aside the broad declarations, saying the statutory provisions could be interpreted and applied consistently with the Constitution.
The judges noted that counties had previously received conditional allocations equivalent to 15 percent of RMLF proceeds for several financial years. However, the arrangement did not create a permanent constitutional entitlement.
From the 2021/2022 financial year, approximately Sh9.8 billion previously disbursed through conditional grants was incorporated into the equitable share allocated to counties.
The National Assembly argued that the change was part of a wider adjustment that increased the equitable share from Sh316.5 billion to Sh370 billion, allowing counties to finance road maintenance alongside other devolved priorities.
The judges agreed that converting conditional grants into the unconditional equitable share was not unconstitutional, noting that it gave counties greater discretion over their spending priorities.
“To insist that county road maintenance must invariably be financed through a conditional allocation from the RMLF would unduly restrict that autonomy and impose a rigidity upon the public-finance framework which the Constitution does not require,” they said.
The court nevertheless cautioned that Parliament's authority to determine the financing mechanism did not give it unfettered discretion.
“We, accordingly, hold that, although the National Assembly was constitutionally entitled to determine whether county-road maintenance should be financed through direct RMLF allocations or through another lawful mechanism, that authority had to be exercised consistently with the constitutional principles governing devolution and intergovernmental relations. In the circumstances disclosed by the record, the Impugned Parliamentary Decisions did not satisfy those requirements,” the judges said.
The court further declined to invalidate the continued existence of the Kenya Rural Roads Authority (Kerra) and Kenya Urban Roads Authority (Kura), saying national agencies could undertake functions assigned to the national government or activities authorised through lawful intergovernmental arrangements.
Lawyer Peter Wanyama, who represented parties challenging Parliament's decision, criticised the judgment, arguing that it weakened county autonomy.
“The judgment effectively preserves a statutory regime (the Kenya Roads Board Act, 1999 and the Kenya Roads Act, 2007) designed for a unitary state. Allowing national parastatals like Kerra and Kura to execute road works inside county jurisdictions using fuel levy funds bypasses county executive oversight and undermines the constitutional autonomy protected under Article 6(2) and Article 189,” he said.
The judges said their decision did not require Parliament to allocate any specific amount of the levy to counties, but insisted that any future decisions affecting devolved functions must comply with constitutional requirements of consultation, cooperation and respect for the institutional roles of both levels of government.