A dispute over Mombasa County's stake in the Buxton estate redevelopment has exposed details of a joint venture agreement that is now at the centre of a bitter confrontation between the county government and the developer.
Rising above Mombasa Island’s neighbourhood, the gleaming towers of Buxton Point were envisioned as a symbol of a new era of modern, affordable urban living. But behind the fresh concrete and glass lies a bitter dispute over one seemingly small but decisive figure: a 10 per cent stake.
Police cool down tension after Mombasa County officials stormed the construction site of the Buxton Point affordable housing project on November 11, 2026, suspending work due to the developer's failure to honour an agreement entitling former tenants to 10 per cent of the housing units.
Photo credit: Kevin Odit | Nation
Under the agreement, it has emerged that the county is entitled to a 10 per cent stake in the residential units and commercial spaces, translating to about 180 units out of the 1,800 planned for the project. That provision has become a major point of contention, threatening to derail a development intended to transform the neighbourhood.
Last week, the county announced that it had halted ongoing construction works through an enforcement notice, prompting the developer to move to court seeking protection against the county’s action.
On November 12, however, the Environment and Land Court in Mombasa declined to certify the application filed by Buxton Point Apartments Limited as urgent and reserved the request to suspend the enforcement notice for consideration after hearing all parties. Buxton Point Apartments Limited is the separate legal entity established by GulfCap Real Estate specifically to implement the Buxton Estate redevelopment project.
Documents filed in court indicate that the company is the developer of Mombasa Block XVII/1821, formerly Mombasa Block XVII/1776, and undertook the project under a joint venture agreement signed with the county on January 15, 2020.
Mombasa County Executive for Lands, Mohamed Hussein Mohamed and other officials stormed the Buxton Point Affordable Housing Project.
Photo credit: Kevin Odit | Nation
Under the agreement, the developer was responsible for undertaking and completing the redevelopment, while the county was required to provide an amalgamated title free from encumbrances, together with the necessary approvals and authorisations.
The arrangement also provided for former tenants to be considered for residential units through a tenant-purchase scheme on favourable terms. However, the developer maintains that the arrangement was intended for the third phase, while the project is currently at phase two.
The agreement further required the developer to provide social amenities, including a community centre, a hospital and an Early Childhood Development and Education (ECDE) facility, for handover at the end of the third phase.
In an affidavit filed in court, site manager Aboud Said Khalifa said the developer has already constructed the ECDE facility, which is currently being used as a site office pending completion of the project and commencement of its intended educational function.
A view of the completed Buxton Point affordable housing development in Mombasa. However, the project continues to be mired in controversy.
Photo credit: Kevin Odit | Nation
The court documents link the latest confrontation to a meeting involving county officials and former tenants on November 10, following an invitation issued on October 30 for a consultative meeting.
According to Mr Khalifa, the meeting turned into a town hall gathering where the county official in charge of the department demanded immediate delivery of the community centre and ECDE facility, notwithstanding the agreed timelines. The developer alleges that the official also incited former tenants against the company before the county issued the enforcement notice shortly after the meeting.
The notice accused the company of undertaking development without the requisite county approvals and deviating from approved building plans. It also cited disputes involving the developer, former tenants and the county government.
However, the company argues that the notice failed to identify the specific unauthorised works, the development conditions allegedly breached or the technical basis for the enforcement action.
“The applicant has not been furnished with the full inspection reports, technical assessments, complaints and other material upon which the Respondents relied,” Mr Khalifa stated in the affidavit.
The developer further maintains that it had obtained development permission and approved building plans before commencing construction and had continued engaging county authorities over the status of its approvals.
Documents filed in court indicate that the company lodged an application to renew or regularise its approvals through the county's e-planning portal in February 2024 under reference AAA8456.
At a follow-up meeting on September 25, 2026, the County Director of Physical Planning returned the application to the project architect for additional documents. The developer says it complied with the request and uploaded the documents, which were awaiting further action by the county.
The former tenants' grievances have also featured in previous court proceedings. According to the application, their tenancies were terminated and the property handed over to the developer free from encumbrances as provided for in the joint venture agreement.
The company cites the dismissal of Mombasa ELC Constitutional Petition No. 28 of 2020, in which former tenants had challenged aspects of the redevelopment, as well as a March 24, 2026 judgment in a separate dispute involving Buxton Filling Station.
A view of the completed Buxton Point affordable housing development in Mombasa. However, the project continues to be mired in controversy.
Photo credit: Kevin Odit | Nation
It argues that the previous proceedings addressed the tenants' grievances and that the latest enforcement action may have been influenced by matters unrelated to the county's statutory planning and enforcement responsibilities.
The developer has since appealed against the enforcement notice before the County Physical and Land Use Planning Liaison Committee. However, it argues that the committee cannot quash the notice or grant interim orders to prevent its implementation, hence its decision to approach the Environment and Land Court.
“The Applicant does not seek to evade or disregard the lawful planning and regulatory requirements applicable to the development but wants the court to follow the law in exercising its enforcement powers,” the affidavit stated.
It added that the company is willing to comply with all lawful planning, building and safety requirements and cooperate with any lawful inspection or verification process.
Buxton Point also warns that stopping construction would disrupt contractual commitments with contractors, consultants and suppliers, expose it to additional costs and potential claims, and delay delivery of the promised social amenities.
“The continued implementation of the impugned Enforcement Notice will occasion substantial financial and operational prejudice,” Mr Khalifa stated.
The court directed the developer to serve the application and supporting documents on the three respondents within three days, giving them 14 days to file their responses. The developer will then have seven days to file a further affidavit and submissions, with the respondents allowed another seven days to respond.
The respondents are the County Executive Committee Member in charge of Lands, Urban Planning and Housing, the County Government of Mombasa and the County Attorney.
The judge also directed the parties to address whether an appeal lodged before the County Physical and Land Use Planning Liaison Committee affects the competence and maintainability of the court proceedings, including whether the developer had exhausted the available statutory dispute-resolution mechanisms. The developer was ordered to provide evidence of the appeal and its current status within 14 days.
In its application, Buxton Point Apartments Limited is seeking to have the November 10 enforcement notice quashed, arguing that it was issued without sufficient detail, proper procedure or consideration of development approvals already granted.
A signed board on the construction of the Buxton Point Affordable Housing Project, which was suspended by the Mombasa County Government over an unfulfilled agreement.
Photo credit: Kevin Odit | Nation
The company also wants the county restrained from taking further enforcement action and ordered to disclose the inspection reports, technical assessments, complaints and reasons behind the decision.
The court made no determination on the validity of the enforcement notice or the merits of the developer's complaints. It also left unresolved the question of whether the pending appeal before the liaison committee affects the court proceedings.
The matter will be mentioned on January 20, 2027, for confirmation of compliance, consideration of any preliminary issues and further directions.