On January 27, 2022, the Kenya Bureau of Standards (Kebs) started evaluating bids for a tender whose winning bidder would inspect used cars and spare parts being imported into Kenya.
Among the bidders was EAA Company Ltd, a firm that the Public Procurement Regulatory Board (PPRB) had issued a three-year ban, just months earlier, for using forged documents and false information in two other similar tenders at Kebs between 2014 and 2017.
The ghost university trail
Some of the documents that EAA Company Ltd submitted for the 2022 Kebs tender were an Automotive Engineering degree certificate for its technical manager from Yokohama University.
The firm also submitted an inspection certificate from the Government of Japan for the same technical manager. For its quality assurance manager, EAA Company Ltd submitted a Risk Management degree certificate from Nihon University.
Also in the bundle were ISO certificates for the quality assurance manager and three other employees. The PPRB has now concluded that Yokohama University does not exist, and that Nihon University did not offer a Risk Management course in 2014 when the quality assurance manager allegedly graduated from that institution.
The ISO certificates, among several other documents submitted, were also forgeries. On March 18, 2025, the PPRB issued EAA Company Ltd with a second three-year ban for once again using forged papers to bid for a Kebs tender. Two days later, the PPRB also issued a second three-year ban for Auto Terminal Japan, another firm that had also been accused of using forged papers and information to bid for the Kebs tenders.
Auto Terminal Japan had also bid for the 2022 tender. Auto Terminal Japan, however, successfully challenged its second ban in court. The firm argued that it had already served its sentence, and that the second ban stemmed from the same set of documents.
The court on August 11, 2025, ruled that the documents that the PPRB relied on for Auto Terminal Japan’s second ban were still under investigation by police, so there was no final finding on their genuineness, making punishment premature.
Japanese tycoons Prosper Sugai, Toyohiko Hashino and Mamoru Fujie now headline a list of eight individuals and two firms being tried for procurement fraud in Kenya’s courts.
Mr Sugai and Mr Hashino are the top two officers at EAA Company Ltd, a Japanese inspection firm with contracts in multiple countries for inspection of used vehicles.
Mr Fujie is a director of Auto Terminal Japan Ltd, which also offers similar services in other countries. The Chief Magistrate’s Court at Milimani Law Courts in Nairobi has issued summonses to Mr Sugai, Mr Hashino, Mr Fujie, EAA Company Ltd, Auto Terminal Japan, Mr Michael Ambunli Alloys, Mr Calvince Omondi, Mr Brian Odhiambo, Mr Isaac Peter and Mr Clive Mshweshwe for purposes of being charged with 40 separate counts of procurement fraud.
The prosecution is in relation to all three bids that EAA Company Ltd and Auto Terminal Japan put in for the Kebs tenders between 2014 and 2022. The winning bidder was to inspect all used motor vehicles and spare parts being imported to Kenya, for a commission that would run into billions over the years of operation.
Star witness and the UK link
The Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (ODPP) will be relying on Mr Lee Raymond Sayer as its star witness. Mr Sayer is a New Zealand national based in Japan, and had been part of EAA Company Ltd’s journey for at least six years.
Prosecutors will be leaning on his past dealings with Mr Sugai and EAA Company Ltd to build a case against the Japanese tycoon and his firm. In Tilbury, a port town in the United Kingdom, Mr Sugai is alleged to have registered a firm named EAA UK Inspections Ltd on February 5, 2019. Mr Sayer was appointed a director of the UK firm, and resigned on November 1, 2024.
The New Zealander is the first on the ODPP’s list of witnesses. Others are Mr Raphael Ngalatu of PPRB’s debarment committee, and Mr Philip Wambugu. British national Mr Christopher James Whitcombe was also appointed director of the UK firm in 2019, and is listed as one of the active board members alongside Mr Sugai and Mr Hashino.
In disclosures to the Companies House in the UK, the firm has indicated that it only has one employee.
For EAA Company Ltd and Auto Terminal Japan, their first flagging happened in 2019 when the Auditor-General’s office conducted a special audit of the pre-export verification of conformity (PVOC) service at Kebs. That flagging would be confirmed by the National Assembly’s Public Investments Committee, the PPRB and the Directorate of Criminal Investigations (DCI).
The special audit report noted that EAA had lied about having 17 inspection centres in Japan and three in the UK as required of bidders. It also found that Mr Sugai had legally changed his name. He was born Guku Prosper Japhet before taking up a new name.
The firm only provided leases for eight centres, some of which did not exist, as found by auditors who visited Japan and the UK. In Japan, it is alleged that one of the centres was owned and operated by a different firm, while another was owned and operated by the eventual winning bidder – Quality Inspection Services Japan.
The firm did not own or operate any centre in the UK. In the Japanese regions of Kisarazu, Kawasaki, Kitakyushu and Moji, EAA Company Ltd did not have any staff or operations as claimed in the bidding documents, investigations show. It also emerged that Mr Sugai owned Rosper International Company Ltd, which he incorporated in 2002.
Conflict of interest and fake yards
Rosper International exports used vehicles and heavy machinery to Kenya and other countries, something the Auditor-General said created a potential conflict of interest for Mr Sugai and EAA Company Ltd if awarded the Kebs inspection tender.
The audit also unearthed several inconsistencies in documents and non-disclosure of EAA Company Ltd’s ISO ban in Japan between 2014 and 2016 for undisclosed reasons.
For Auto Terminal Japan, the audit found that Mr Fujie had failed to indicate that he has no shares in the firm, which was actually owned by Tetsuro Shirahama, despite being furnished with a confidential business questionnaire in which such information was to be provided to Kebs.
Auto Terminal Japan had claimed to own 16 inspection centres in Japan alone. One of the centres visited by auditors was actually a piece of land leased by the Japanese firm for a car export business only. Another centre marketed in bid documents as having state-of-the-art testing equipment only hosted a dilapidated building.
And, much like it was with EAA Company Ltd, one of the centres listed as Auto Terminal Japan’s, was actually an operation inspection site owned and operated by Quality Inspection Services Japan, the eventual winning bidder.
Auto Terminal Japan did not own any inspection centre, and is also alleged to have forged a letter from a non-existent law firm in the UK stating that it had inspection centres in Bristol City.
Alongside those, Auto Terminal Japan had attached several forged invoices, sale agreements and other documents in an attempt to meet the tender requirements such as having operating inspection sites in Japan, the UK and the UAE.
While serving the first three-year ban in Kenya, EAA Company Ltd had government contracts for inspection of second hand vehicles in Zambia, Uganda, Tanzania, Mauritius and Bahamas.
Auto Terminal Japan on its part has had similar contracts in Uganda, Guyana, Pakistan, Jamaica and Zambia.