There’s something terribly unethical about a journalist getting paid to put out an opinion, be it political, social, or commercial, as their own.
Reports in the United States that Laura Loomer, one of President Donald Trump’s biggest online acolytes, was paid thousands of dollars for political tweets have kicked up a storm. According to the Washington Post, the allegations were made by Alex Bruesewitz, an advisor to President Trump’s 2024 campaign, and three unnamed people. The Post also states that Ms Loomer denied the allegations. She maintains that Mr Bruesewitz had paid her to undertake research.
The Post reports that Ms Loomer’s detractors have lamented that several high-ranking defence and national security officials have been dismissed after she publicly rebuked them, often on her X account, and that President Trump called her a “very nice person” and a “patriot” last year.
The controversy surrounding Ms Loomer, who describes herself on X as an investigative journalist, free spirit, founder of LOOMERED, among others, and has 1.9 million followers on that platform, carries lessons for Kenya, especially in the run-up to the General Election next year.
Kenya’s online space, which is a major battleground for political supremacy, is teeming with political influencers. A number are credible academicians and professionals who have amassed online followers through consistent engagement in and contribution to public discourse on pertinent issues. Others are self-styled political analysts who have perfected their art through regular participation in television and radio talk shows.
Then there are the hundreds of keyboard warriors, most of whom hide behind fictitious names, who are paid to spew hatred and falsehoods to either promote or discredit political leaders.
Discerning consumers of online content have learned to distinguish these categories, knowing well that the information from keyboard warriors is sponsored and must be taken with a pinch of salt.
But when a well-known personality puts out a statement, consumers assume that he or she is the originator of the thought or idea. They would be clearly disappointed and feel betrayed if they discovered that their political opinion shapers have actually been paid to express certain sentiments. They would consider it deception.
Does this situation call for some form of regulation to compel influencers to disclose who has paid them to say what? Should the standards that apply to legacy media, which face stringent guidelines on political advertisers, also apply to paid digital partnerships with influencers? How would these be reinforced? Agencies like the electoral commission should think about this ahead of the polls.
Ms Loomer’s story may not have warranted as much of our attention if she hadn’t been calling herself a journalist. The journalist tag carries a heavy responsibility. Journalism is a high calling with trust as its main currency. Journalists cultivate trust with their consumers by being ethical in their journalistic undertakings. They follow the established code of practice, demonstrating core tenets of journalism like accuracy, independence, and transparency.
There’s something terribly unethical about a journalist getting paid to put out an opinion, be it political, social, or commercial, as their own. In doing this, they replace independent content with paid advertising or promotion, but fail to disclose this. It is an abuse of the trust his or her audiences have in the journalist, and damages the credibility of the journalist, the media house and the profession as a whole.
The thinning lines between journalism and enterprise, where journalists boldly endorse products, are equally worrying. Such journalists and their media houses risk not only losing their independence and credibility, but also setting themselves up for a conflict of interest situation.
When a journalist endorses a product because they or their media house have been paid to do so, pray how will they report objectively should the same product be found to have a fault in the future? Additionally, can the producer of a rival product trust this journalist, or the media house, to provide them with fair coverage? Might the producer of the rival product consider friends of their rivals their rivals, and opt to take their own advertising business elsewhere? These are questions journalists and their media houses must ponder before getting into partnerships with advertisers that could undermine their credibility.
But while product endorsement is obvious to the consumer, political endorsement or discrediting can remain subtle and hidden from public view, only surfacing when the payers make the disclosure.
The repercussions can be dire: In the 1990s, a senior editor and popular columnist resigned after he admitted to receiving money from a political party. This (admission and resignation) was, and remains, rare.
Follow ourWhatsApp channel for breaking news updates and more stories like this.
Contact the Public Editor to raise ethical concerns or request a review of published material. Reach out: Email: [email protected]. Mobile number: 0741978786.